The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings







Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review

The world's at war
Rules are suspended
Whole world's. . .upended!
Quick let's click

— Artie introducing young Stu to the pleasures of the flesh with a snappy song and tap dance routine.
Bobby Steggert and Ivan Hernandez
(Photo: Carol Rosegg)
In the last couple of weeks I've seen the gay experience animated circa 1959, 1968 and 2009. Alexi Kaye Campbell's The Pride covered both the uptight and deeply closeted attitudes of 1958 and the less constrained 2009 (review). Mart Crowley's The Boys In the Band, the first play to "out" the gay experience for mainstream audiences, dished up 1968 style gay-think (review). Just a day after re-experiencing Crowley's volatile birthday party in a Chelsea loft, I headed to the York Theater for the Zellnik Brothers' (composer Joseph and bookwriter/lyricist David) musical salute to gays in the military during World War II. The lovers at the center of this historical romance makes Don't Ask Don't Tell a cakewalk in comparison to the undercover existence of men and women in uniform in the 1940s.

Yank! first saw the light of day at the 2005 New York Musical Theater Festival. It had a brief run with the Brooklyn Gallery Players last year which is when Bobby Steggert came aboard as the show's hero and Nancy Anderson as the one female to assume multiple personas with a flip of a wig and a new costume. To prove the validity of the old cliché about the silver lining to be found in every cloud, Yank!'s move to the York Theatre Company, that invaluable incubator of new musicals, again has Steggert in the lead due to the sadly premature closing of the Broadway revival of Ragtime (review) in which he was sensational as the revolution smitten Younger Brother.

You couldn't wish for a more engaging actor than Steggert to play Stu, the young innocent who as a World War II draftee learns about life, soldierly solidarity ("Your Squad Is Your Squad"), the horrors of war and, of course love (—- a love that dare not show itself and certainly should not be recorded in a journal. But though Stu is this nostalgic wartime story's pivotal character, the York production also boasts a strong ensemble to portray its cross section of soldiers from all walks of life. That includes the charismatic Jeffry Denman who, besides enlivening the stage as the quick-talking, fleet-footed Artie Goldberg, is the man responsible for the choreography that boosts Yank!'s watchability factor.

The chameleon Nancy Anderson, who did a similar all-the-women gig in Jolson & Co (also at the York, in 1999), is also aboard and terrific — whether she's a mom sending her boy to basic training, a Betty Grable pinup girl, an Andrew Sisters type or USO singer, a pragmatic officer or a nurse in a cleverly stagedly corny B- movie.

Yank! is the kind of old-fashioned musical that makes you feel as if you're watching an amalgam of World War II movies and listening to some old long playing records of swing music by the Glenn Miller band and the Andrew sisters. Thus, if all the characters seem a little like stereotypes of the G.I. Joes who were thrown together in a war fought by an across-the-board draft rather than a volunteer service corps, that's part of this show's charm and intent. It's a memory piece triggered by a diary found in a junk shop by Steggert who, as narrator/story teller merges into the character of the diary's author. The ensuing story as well as the songs explore the pastiche genre. It's a typically bittersweet wartime love story, except that it's Stu and not a girl who falls in love with Mitch who epitomizes the tall, dark and handsome leading men of this period.

The diary device effectively launches this musical trip down this well traveled but ever emotionally engaging and historically interesting memory lane. The pastiche songs are pleasant and melodic and the lyrics don't strain unnecessarily for their rhymes. It would be nice if at least a few of the songs created to evoke their role models would also be the sort of breakout tunes that embed themselves in your ear. That said, it's unfair to judge a musical score on a first encounter and though you're not likely to be humming a single Yank! tune as you exit the theater or during your morning shower, the songs are enjoyable and apt within the context of the book.

Most importantly, Jeffry Denman's choreography goes a long way to bring out the best in the Zellnik score. " Click," the tap-dancing number that bring's Denman on stage as the fun loving, unabashedly gay Artie is a case in point. The way Artie indoctrinates Stu to the possibilities of sexual adventures cleverly and enjoyably integrates plot, music and dance ("The world's at war/rule are suspended/ whole world's . . .upended!/ quick let's click").

Considering the size of the performance space Denman's using the pastiche genre to introduce an Oklahoma-like dream ballet is dazzling for its can-do daring even though the end result feels somewhat clunky in this confined space. As for the staging overall, Igor Goldin's direction keeps the pace steady and insures that the snapshot journal entries transition smoothly into active scenes.

Ray Klausen relies on the book and the performers to carry the story forward without glitzy scenery. A few basic props and some large deftly re-arranged moveable panels steer us through Stu's boy to manhood saga — from his basic training. . . to his stint as a photographer for Yank, the weekly Army magazine from which the play takes its title . . . to a post-war veteran's hospital. At one point those panels and much used bunk bed create a raised screen for Nancy Anderson to do her bit in that already mentioned B-movie weepie.

Klausen's scenic design includes a handsome proscenium covered with Life-look-alike covers of Yank, the magazine for which the musical takes its name. The magazine also gets a peppy song for Stu and the ensemble (It ain't for the fickle//And it's only a nickel/Just regular types/Airing their gripes/Not sentimental like Stars and Stripes).

Tricia Barsamian's costumes contribute mightily to all of Nancy Anderson's character switches though, according to an audience member who's a World War II veteran, there are a few minor inaccuracies in the sargeant's gear (the Eisenhower style short jackets weren't worn during the years depicted and his status does not call for an officer's hat).

A scene in which Stu defends his working for Yank instead of wielding a gun to Mitch is something of a precursor to political action for equality for blacks (who were segregated and relegated to non-career service until Harry Truman's presidency) and gays in the military ("No going back--not now/Too many know to go back and hide/To go back in disguise/ hundreds of thousands/Who felt lost and alone before/Have found each other in the war"). However, per the title tag, a WWII Love Story, this is first and foremost a musical romance. The Zellnik brothers are leaving it to Congress to duke it out over the repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell. Their aim is to dish up entertainment with a big dollop nostalgia and hearttug. Their message, in a tweet: It takes as much courage to make love as to make war.
Music by Joseph Zellnik
Book and lyrics by David Zellnik
Directed by Igor Goldin
Music director: John Baxindine
Choreographer: Jeffry Denman
Cast: Nancy Anderson (Women), Bobby Steggert (Stu), Jeffry Denman (Artie), Ivan Hernandez (Mitch), Andrew Durand (Tennessee), Zak Edwards (Melanie), Todd Faulkner (Sarge/Scarlett), Denis Lambert (Lieutenant/Dream Mitch), Joseph Medeiros (Dream Stu), David Perlman (Rotelli), Christopher Ruth (Professor),Tally Sessions (Czechowski)
Set design: by Ray Klausen
Costume design: Tricia Barsamian
Lighting design: Ken Lapham
Wig and hair design: Ashley Ryan
Musical arrangements: Joseph Zellnik
Orchestra: John Baxindine (Piano/conductor)k Adam Wachter (Keyboards), ToddGroves (Flute, Clarinet, Alto Saxe), (Allison Seidner (Cello), Jay Mack (Drums)
Stage Manager: Kimothy Cruse
Running Time: 2 hours plus 10-minute intermission
York Theatre at Saint Peter's box office (Enter on 54th Street, Just East of Lexington), (212) 935-5820
From 2/16/10; opening 2/24/10; closing 4/04/10
Tickets are $67.50
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer February 19th press performance
Musical Numbers
Act One
  • Remembering You/Mitch
  • Yank!/Stu & ensemble
  • Polishing Shoes/Czekowski, Tennessee, Mitch, Stu
  • Saddest Gal What Am/Helen & boys
  • Betty/Tennessee,Czekowski, Mitch
  • Click/Artie, Stu
  • Remembering You - Letters/Professor, Rotelli, Stu
  • Blue Twilight/Estelle
  • Yank! (Reprise)/Squad
  • A Couple of Regular Guys/Mitch & Stu
Act Two
  • Movie Night: The Bright Beyond!/Nurse
  • Your Squad is Your Squad/Czekowski, Professor Rotelli, Stu, Mitch
  • Credit to the Uniform/Louise, Artie, Stu, Three Soldiers
  • Just True/ Stu & Mitch
  • Stuck in a Cell/Scalett, Melanie
  • Ballet/Dream Stu, Dream Mitch, Ensemble
  • A Couple of Regular Guys (Reprise)/Stu
  • Remembering You (Reprise)/ Mitch
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Yank!
  • I disagree with the review of Yank!
  • The review made me eager to see Yank!
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

You can also contact us at Curtainup at Facebook , Curtainup at Twitter and at our Blog Annex
Subscribe to our FREE email updates with a note from editor Elyse Sommer about additions to the website -- with main page hot links to the latest features posted at our numerous locations. To subscribe, E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message -- if you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
South Pacific  Revival
South Pacific

In the Heights
In the Heights

Playbill Broadway Yearbook


©Copyright 2010, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from