The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings







Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review
Why We Left Brooklyn
or The Dinner Party Play
"I've lived in Hoboken. I've lived in Astoria. I've lived in Kensington. I've lived in midtown. I've lived in Park Slope. I've basically lived in every borough but the Bronx. So, what? Something I missed? You do realize there are things everywhere, just like they are here. " — Jason, explaining his move to Columbus, Ohio to his Park Slope friends, a number of whom he persuaded to give New York a whirl twelve years ago, when they graduated from college.
Why We Left Brooklyn
Susan Louise O'Connor and Andrew Schwartz (Photo credit: Kyle Ancowitz)
Brooklyn, though long home to emerging creative types, didn't always rival Manhattan as a high rent "in" place to live. Neighborhoods once not only cheap but somewhat dangerous to live in, have become hot and trendy, Park Slope being the crème-de-la-crème of all these enclaves.

So why would anyone leave a place with so many amenities nowadays associated with the good life — lots of cafes and gourmet food shops and farmer's markets, yoga classes, and most importantly, a circle of like-minded circle of friends. For starters, there's of course the incredibly high cost, especially with a lasting recession that's in full swing in 2010 which is when Matthew Freeman's Why I Left Brooklyn takes place.

Jason is Freeman's trigger character to explore the ripple effect his move Columbus, Ohio to teach at a college. To start with, there's the fact that Jason isn't just answering the knock of opportunity for a steady job and more affordable housing, but doing so as part of a tough look at the limitations of his talent. Add to that the effect on his 8-year marriage. Though he and Michelle are still in love and she's agreed to give up her day job, her ambitions as a writer have been realized with a book deal. The fact that her publisher wants her to be in New York to promote the book when it comes out, has resulted in a change in plans: Michelle will be staying with neighborhood friends, Jason's college buddy and fellow actor George (David DelGrosso) and his wife Franny (Marguerite Simpson) and join Jason at a later, as yet unspecified, date.

Though temporary, the unplanned separation does create marital tension and, unsurprisingly, kicks up underlying problems. The playwright ratchets up the tensions of this combination move and temporary separation by having Jason and Michelle throw a night-before the exodus dinner party with packing boxes substituting for a dinner dining table.

Jason expects his friends to be happy for him and wish him well, and indeed there's a good deal of bonhomie as the guests arrive. However, the gathering unspools a good deal of anger about this leaving of Brooklyn. George, especially sees Jason's Ohio sojourn as an abandonment and introduces a debate-like confrontation into the party, a debate which in turn exacerbates the Jason-Michelle marital dynamic.

All but two of the guests are old friends: Besides Franny and George, there's the eccentric Charlie (Matthew Trumbull), another college mate and actor; the outspoken Nicole (Moira Stone), the only member of the group who has opted for motherhood; the colorful but unfocused Leeanna (Sarah K. Lippmann), who's unmarried, as is Dawn (Rebecca Gray Davis), who is gainfully and successfully employed by a museum. The two outsiders are Leeanna's boyfriend, restaurateur Harry (Jay Leibowitz) and Sanjeet (Imran Sheikh) a new man in Dawn's life.

Plays with casts this large are nowadays rarely seen except in revivals by well-known playwrights. New plays, even by established scribes tend to be geared to a theater economy that prefers no more than four actors. Only small companies used to putting on low-budget productions like Theater Accident and Blue Coyote Theater Group who are co-producing Why We Left Brooklyn can accommodate a cast of ten. That large cast allows Mr. Freeman to make this as much an amusing portrait of a particular segment of the Big Apple's culture as well a drama about Jason and Michelle's marriage and Jason and George's friendship. Harry and Sanjeet broaden the Park Slope portrait.

As it turns out, however, Mr. Freeman would have done better to not indulge himself with quite this big a cast. Sure, this allows him to take a stab at a Shavian style discussion play that covers everything from trendy food to yoga to politics. But the result, though often amusing, is too talky and overstuffed. I kept thinking of Donald Margulies's Dinner With Friends which focused on two couples who were close friends for years so that the divorce of one pair stirred up unintended feelings of anger and jealousy in the still married pair. It wasn't the most original story ever told, but it won a Pulitzer because the characters and situation were so believably and fully developed.

While one would not be wrong to expect a play set in 2010 to be relevant to the economic upheavals Americans everywhere have been and are still experiencing this is basically just another play about actors for whom frequent and long periods of unemployment or underpaid and unsuccessful gigs are par for the course in good as well as bad times. There are other questionable aspects to the basic premise. Jason's job is a somewhat questionable opportunity. It's not as if a teaching job at a college anywhere held even the remotest promise of tenure, health care and pension benefits as was once a case. Adjuncts tend to be underpaid and under appreciated.

As for Michelle's need to stay in New York to promote her book, this too begs a closer look. Nowadays the big promotional push for books is via the internet and even big name authors have fewer New York and other big market television interview opportunities. So much for Michelle, an unknown author with a small press. (I can personally attest to this, having just published a new edition of one of my books with a small publisher).

In this production, smaller would have avoided the sense that some of these characters have been brought on scene mostly as an excuse to send up some aspect of Park Slope life. (Interestingly, much as I enjoy a full sized cast this is the second play I've seen this week with a large cast that wasn't really in the best interest of the play's structure). I should add that the cast features some excellent performances though none are on a par with Matthew Trumbull's wonderfully eccentric Charlie. Director Kyle Ancowitz would have been well advised to persuade the playwright to trim his script so that it could be performed in 90 minutes without an intermission. In a theater without a lobby or drinks and candy setup and a play with a bare bones single set, the two five-minute intermissions seem rather pointless.

All my quibbles aside, Mr. Freeman knows his Park Slope from first-hand experience. He's unlikely to give up playwriting even if his plays don't become long-running hits. Fortunately, unlike Jason, he doesn't have to move to Ohio to pay his own Park Slope rent. Like many actors and playwrights living in New York he's managed to find a day job he likes right in the Big Apple. Of course, if Jason had gotten a teaching gig right here, there wouldn't have been a play.

Why We Left Brooklyn by Matthew Freeman
Directed by Kyle Ancowitz
Cast: Rebecca Gray Davis (Dawn), David DelGrosso (George), Jay Leibowitz (Harry), Sarah K. Lippmann (Leanna, Sarah Louise O'Connor (Michelle), Andrew Schwartz (Jason) Imran Sheikh (Sanjeet), Marguerite Simpson (Franny), Moira Stone (Nicole), Matthew Trumbull (Charlie),
Sets: Kerry Lee Chipman
Costumes: Caroline Berti
Lighting: Nicholas Houfek
Sound: Kyle Ancowitz
Stage Manager: Kaitlin Nemeth
Running Time: Approximately 2 hours with two 5-minute intermissions Fourth Street Theater 83 East 4th Street, between Bowery & Second Avenue 212-868-4444  
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer at 8/30/13 press preview
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Why We Left Brooklyn or The Dinner Party Play
  • I disagree with the review of Why We Left Brooklyn or The Dinner Party Play
  • The review made me eager to see Why We Left Brooklyn or The Dinner Party Play
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted add to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter
Subscribe to our FREE email updates: E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message. If you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
Slings & Arrows  cover of  new Blu-Ray cover
Slings & Arrows- view 1st episode free

Book Of Mormon MP4 Book of Mormon -CD
Our review of the show

©Copyright 2013, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from