The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings







Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Berkshire Review
Scott and Hem in the Garden of Allah

"Every good story's a war story." — Miss Evelyn Montaigne, the scene stealing blonde bombshell in Mark St. Germain's latest play about a conversational "war" between two famous men.
Scott and Hem
Joey Collins and Ted Koch (Photo credit: Kevin Sprague)
The Scott and Hem of Mark St. Germaine's latest imagined confrontation between two famous men are F. Scott Fitzgerald and Ernest Hemingway. The setting is an apartment in a now gone Hollywood real estate landmark, named "The Garden of Allah" by the original owner, film diva Alia Nazimova and which, like The Chelsea Hotel in New York,was home to many famous writers and actors. The year is 1937, long before the portmanteau word "frenemies" (alternately spelled "frienemies") came into usage to describe friends whose relationship varies enough to often make them enemies.

Sigmund Freud and C. S. Lewis of Freud's Last Session , one of Barrington Stage Company's biggest hits (many extensions in Pittsfield a long runnin New York and productionsall over the world) had widely different beliefs, they were neither friends or enemies. But that portmanteau coinage perfectly fits this new play about Fitzgerald and Hemingway at a critical juncture of their literary careers and personal lives. Their friendship bloomed during their expatriate days in the '20s when the already successful Fitzgerald generously helped the still lesser known Hemingway to become part of the famous editor Maxwell Perkins' stable of literary lions. It cooled in the years that followed, when Hemingway's reputation soared and Fitzgerald was at a point were he seemed unlikely to ever write another novel with the star power of The Great Gatsby.

Mr. St. Germaine clearly has a feel for using well known and much written about details pertaining to world renowned men and working them into dramas that hold our attention even though the result is essentially a conversational debate. Though mere slices from these dramaticaly paired lives, we come away with lots of ideas to chew over.

Scott and Hem in the Garden of Allah is no exception. While Lewis wasn't quite as famous as Freud, both Fitzgerald and Hemingway rank high on the list of accomplished men whose names ring an instant bell. Their work and though perhaps not read as much these days as before remain in print. The Great Gatsby especially has maintained its currency with repeated attempts to get it right as a film. There are also the avante-garde Elevator Repair Service company's word-for-word reenactments of The Great Gatsby and The Sun Also Rises ( Review of Fitzgerald's novel and Review of Hengway's .

There's also no shortage of facts to support St. Germaine's imagined meeting and its unpacking of the men's personal and professional past and future and the dynamic between them: Biographies, autobiographies, published and unpublished letters — so many that Fitzgerald and Hemingway watchers are unlikely to learn anything new. That said, however, Scott and Hem in the Garden of Allah rises above the too familiar with a script chock full of terrific dialogue and enlivened by cleverly inserted name dropping (Picasso, Gertrude Stein, Dorothy Parker, Gerald and Sara Murphy,and more).

To give his "war story" dramatic tension and structure, St. Germain has Fitzgerald sequestered with a tough studio assistant instructed by Louis B. Mayer to keep him sober and working on a screen play of Maria Remarque's novel Three Comrades while worrying about having done the right thing to institutionalize his beloved wife Zelda.

Though never seen, Zelda is an ever present ghost haunting both her husband and Scott and Hemingway and her madness and suicidal tendencies create some of the tensest moments during Hemingway's visit. That visit is prompted by his actually being in town for a screening of a documentary about the Spanish Civil War. The plot, such as it is, entails reminiscences, discussions about writing, fame, gender, and Hemingway's trying to badger Fitzgerald into resuming his more serious writing even though he declares that he's "left the game" that in the past year earned him a grand total of less than $20 in royalties.

One of the best new wrinkles to the playwright's paired discussion plays genre is the addition of a third character, the sarcastic studio watchdog Miss Evelyn Montaigne who, as superbly played by Angela Pierce, is an entertaining and important Scott-Hem go-between. Her prevenint Hemingway's visit from disrupting Fitzgerald's completion of the screenplay is also crucial to her own ambitions to rise out of mostly secretarial chores to a real career in a still sexist Hollywood.

Pierce's gorgeous harridan has been given the play's sharpest lines. And though her final scene with Collins's Fitzgerald is somewhat too abrupt and out of character, viewers familiar with the Fitzgerald legend may well see this as a metamorphoses of Montaignee into Sheila Graham, the gossip columnist who actually lived with Fitzgerald during his Hollywood days.

While Pierce's blonde bombshell is Scott and Hem in the Garden of Allah's scene stealer and the play's most original and best developed character, that's not to say that the actors playing the title characters don't inhabit them with subtlety and believability. Joey Collins is like Pierce is reprising his Scott from the play's first production at the Contemporary American Theatre Festival's first production in Sheperdstown, West Virgia (CATO actually commissioned the play, and Barrington Stage has extended it into a 2-way world premiere). Ted Koch's Hemingway makes for a powerful contrast to Collins's gentler more soft-spoken Scott. Koch actually looks a lot like the real Hemingway.

Though playwrights directing their own plays often turns out to be a less than ideal arrangement, in this case St. Germain wears his two hats without mishap. He keeps things moving along briskly and is strongly supported by David M. Barber and Margaret A. McKowen's period perfect scenery and costumes. Strong contributions are also z by lighting and sound designers Scott Pinkney Jessica Paz, and fight Ryan Winkle expertly navigates the fight scene that culminates wotj a decidedly unfriendly climax to Hemingway's visit.

I'm not sure this play will have the "legs" of Freud's Last Session, but it's entertaining, well written and acted, and well worth a visit to Pittsfield. Of course, interesting as these men were, it's not a bad idea to pay tribute to their outstanding contribution to literature by re-reading some of their work.

Scott and Hem in the Garden of Allah
Written and Directed by Mark St. Germain
Cast: Joey Collins (F. Scott Fitzgerald), Ted Koch (Ernest Hemingway), Angela Pierce (Miss Evelyn Montaigne)
Scenice Design: David M. Barber
Costumes: Margaret A. McKowen
Lighting Design:a Scott Pinkney
Sound Design: Jessica Paz
Stage Manager Lori M. Doyle
Barrington St. Germain Stage
Running Time: 85 Minutes, no intermission
Aug 15, 2013 - Sep 29, 2013
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer at August 21st press opening
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Scott and Hem in the Garden of Allah
  • I disagree with the review of Scott and Hem in the Garden of Allah
  • The review made me eager to see Scott and Hem in the Garden of Allah
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted add to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter
Subscribe to our FREE email updates: E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message. If you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
Slings & Arrows  cover of  new Blu-Ray cover
Slings & Arrows- view 1st episode free

Book Of Mormon MP4 Book of Mormon -CD
Our review of the show

©Copyright 2013, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from