The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings





Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants









Free Updates
Writing for Us
A CurtainUp Review
Room Service

Room Service Gets Yet Another Life.

Our critic was one of numerous yea sayers for this revival. And so, like Counsellor-at-Lawand Talk of the Town, several extensions have now been followed by a move to another venue. In the case of Room Service, the show stayed off-off-Broadway, with this second run at the Soho Playhouse,15 Vandam St.. (6th/7th Avs), (212) 691-1555,
The 1937 screwball comedy by John Murray & Allen Boretz was extended several time and so, like From11/18/06 to 1/07/07; official l re-opening 11/28/06. Wednesdays through Fridays at 8PM; Saturdays at 3 & 8PM; Sundays at 3 & 7PM; Mondays at 8PM. All tickets are $65 with a limited number of Cheap Seats at $29.99. Below the original review. —esommer.

I'm a member of Actors Equity, and I'm also a member of the Waiters Union. (pause) You know, it's not easy to get into the Waiters Union… --- Sasha Smirnoff

David Edwards, Scott Evans, Fred Berman  in Room Service
David Edwards, Scott Evans, Fred Berman in Room Service
(Photo: Dick Larson)
Director Dan Wackerman comments in his program notes for The Peccadillo Theater Company's new revival of Room Service that "in troubled times, people turn to farce." If this is true, then John Murray and Allen Boretz's play must have arrived at just the right time.

Originally produced in 1937 during the height of the Great Depression, Room Service was a big success, playing for over five hundred performances and inspiring two film versions (one by the Marx Brothers) and a number of revivals both in and out of New York City over the years. Seventy years after its first appearance, one might wonder what it could possibly say to a modern audience--but I'm pleased to report that the Peccadillo's new version is just as funny and relevant today as when the work first appeared, and the time is again just right to see it.

Like most farces, the play relies on snappy dialogue, slapstick comedy and a wickedly fast pace, so thinking too carefully about the convoluted plot isn't recommended. Gordon Miller (David Edwards), a producer, is staying in the hotel of his kind-hearted but perpetually nervous brother-in-law Joseph Gribble (Dale Carman) with the entire cast of his new production, Godspeed. Miller, a blustery fast-talker always on the edge either of success or bankruptcy, is convinced that his new play will finally get him clear of his debts. But in the meantime he has fallen even deeper in debt to the hotel, and the simultaneous arrival of the playwright Leo Davis (Scott Evans) and Gribble's boss Gregory Wagner (Sterling Coyne), who has strict instructions to get the hotel's finances in order, bring the situation to a boiling point. Miller has somehow to find a backer for the play, keep Davis from deserting for a rival producer, and Wagner from throwing him and his cast out on their ear. Predictably, all of this has to happen within twenty-four hours.

It all looks crazy and manic (and the set of Miller's hotel room, expertly designed by Chris Jones, has the appropriate amount of slamming doors to heighten the tension), but this apparent chaos masks a tightly written play and exceptional direction by Wackerman. It's always funny, yet rarely awkward. . .  a difficult thing to pull off in a farce under any circumstances. And it's all made better by the play's physicality which is a daring gamble that pays off brilliantly. Characters pull on and take off whole wardrobes of clothes, come out dripping wet from half-completed showers, and eat real hotel meals. Done wrong this could seem amateurish to the extreme, but here it heightens the audience's sense that they are in Miller's hotel room with him watching a host of near disasters and improbable last minute reprieves. (The inside jokes don't hurt either-- eccentric director Harry Binion's (Fred Berman) announcement that he has caught a vision of a whole new art form -- "no audience, no scenery, just a theater filled with critics" -- seemed particularly inspired on press night.)

But even with a good play, fine direction, and good design (the costumes, designed by Gail Cooper-Hecht, are just right), a farce will fall apart without a great cast. . . and it's this which is perhaps the greatest strength of the whole production. Carman and Evans handle their roles with professionalism and taste, and the rest of the actors are almost all just as good. Robert O'Gorman turns in a fine performance as Miller's assistant Faker Englund. Louis Michael Sacco plays both Sasha Smirnoff (the Russian waiter turned actor) and Senator Blake, president of the hotel chain, with surprising effectiveness. Sterling Coyne starts slowly as Wagner but picks up steam as the play goes on. Kim Rachelle Harris plays the role of the actress Christine Marlowe (reference clearly intended) like a woman straight out of a latter-day Great Gatsby, and Berman manages his director Binion with a fine balance of oddity and charm.

The best performance of all comes from Edwards, who is simply brilliant. If his portrayal of Miller feels as if it's got a lot of Max Bialystock in it, it should, since he played that role in the traveling company of The Producers (even Nathan Lane would admire the combination of roguishness, quick wit and ultimately deep compassion which Edwards brings to his producer). With a lesser performance it would be easy to dismiss or become irritated by his character, but here the audience rightfully roots for him to succeed.

There are some minor hiccups here and there: a couple of the actors don't quite measure up to the rest of the cast, and the show's energy flags slightly towards the end of the second act (of three). However, even bringing this up seems petty in light of the overall quality.

If farce does indeed work best in troubled times, then this seems as good an era as any to revive Room Service.; If you want a reprieve from disturbing reality, go see this exceptional production as soon as possible. This is absolutely as good as it gets.

Background Postscript: The 1937 Broadway version from which the Marx Brothers movie was made was directed by George Abbott starred Sam Levene, Eddie Albert and Betty Field. There was also a 1944 musical film entitled Step Lively which starred Frank Sinatra .

Playwright: John Murray and Allen Boretz
Director: Dan Wackerman
Cast: Fred Berman (Harry Binion), Dale Carman (Joseph Gribble), Jerry Coyle (Dr. Glass), Sterling Coyne (Gregory Wagner), David Edwards (Gordon Miller), Scott Evans (Leo Davis), Blythe Gruda (Hilda Manney), Kim Rachelle Harris (Christine Marlowe), Robert O'Gorman (Faker Englund), Louis Michael Sacco (Sasha Smirnoff and Senator Blake), Raymond Thorne (Simon Jenkins), Dennis Wit (Timothy Hogarth and Bank Messenger)
General Manager: Olson Rohdes
Production Stage Manager: Scott Earley
Scenic Design: Chris Jones
Costume Design: Gail Cooper-Hecht
Lighting Design: Jeffrey E. Salzberg
Running time: 2 hours in three acts, including fifteen minute intermission after Act One
The Bank Street Theatre, 155 Bank St., (212) 633-6533
Web Site:
From 7/06/06 through 8/05/06--extemded to 3/27/07and again to 4/28/07; opening 7/06/06
Thurs. - Sat. @ 8 p.m., Sun. @ 3 p.m.
Tickets: $20 for all performances

Reviewed by Gregory Wilson based on July 10th press performance

Stage Plays
The Internet Theatre Bookshop "Virtually Every Play in the World" --even out of print plays

Playbill Broadway Year Book
The new annual to dress up every Broadway lover's coffee table

broadway musicals: the 101 greatest shows of all time
Easy-on-the budget super gift for yourself and your musical loving friends. Tons of gorgeous pictures.

Leonard Maltin's Classic Movie Guide
Leonard Maltin's 2006 Movie Guide

tales from shakespeare
Retold by Tina Packer of Shakespeare & Co.
Click image to buy.
Our Review

Leonard Maltin's 2005 Movie Guide

Ridiculous! The Theatrical Life and Times of Charles Ludlam
Ridiculous!The Theatrical Life & Times of Charles Ludlam

metaphors dictionary cover
6, 500 Comparative Phrases including 800 Shakespearean Metaphors by our editor.
Click image to buy.
Go here for details and larger image.

The Broadway Theatre Archive


©Copyright 2006, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from