The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings

Search Curtainup








NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review
Our New Girl

Look I am completely aware that none of this is your doing Annie and as I said I'm absolutely not blaming you for. . .My husband is a very - headstrong person. And he's a doctor so - you know - there's a whole ego at play.And clearly he has just decided from his hide-out in Haiti that he knows what's best for me and his son but in fact the last thing on earth I want is a nanny. You know.I don't need a nanny.Annie.
— Hazel
 Our New Girl
L-R: Mary McCann and Lisa Joyce (Photo: Kevin Thomas Garcia )
With Our New Girl, Irish playwright Nancy Harris treads familiar territory and a much explored theme. So welcome to another dysfunctional modern family, in this case an upscale London couple with a problem child.

The central theme revolves around the conflicts special to a high-powered professional woman when she has a child. Can she have it all? Should she have it all? Or are high level careers and motherhood incompatible?

What saves this from being done in by comparisons to similarly themed dramas, movies and books is that Harris knows how to create dramatic tension. A wordless, gasp-inducing opening scene involving the play's youngest cast member and a knife will have theater buffs wondering if it will evolve into a variation of Chekhov's gun. Harris's knack for integrating powerful silent moments into her characters' interchanges make scenes in which what you've anticipated comes to pass somehow feel fresh.

Harris has created characters whose individual flaws and agenda mesh into a watchable whole. Hazel, the to have or not have it all main character, is the most complex. As was the case with the Bush Theater production reviewed by our London critic Lizzie Loveridge ( review ), the audience's continued involvement with the story owes much to the actress playing her. Fortunately Atlantic Theater founding member Mary McCann does not disappoint.
McCann gives a formidable performance as the highly pregnant and frazzled Hazel who has given up her career as a high powered lawyer to run a home-based business in order to be full-time care taker to her eight year old son Daniel (Henry Kelemen, a 10-year-old with numerous film roles under his belt making an impressive stage debut).

Judging from the sleek kitchen with a large abstract painting that might even be a Franz Kline original, finances are not an issue. However, that slick but not especially homey (or convenient for a cook) kitchen apparently symbolizes the problems triggered by Hazel's decision to give up a prestigious career and have a second child.

Daniel has been a difficult child since birth and having his mother home has exacerbated his quirky eating and sleep habits. This, plus behavior difficulties in school, does little to make for an idyllic mother-son relationship. What's more, the savvy former lawyer has impulsively jumped into a home business venture inspired by an earth mother type Italian woman she met on a holiday. But th3 imported olive oil venture is hardly off to a promising start.

As if the troublesome child and equally troublesome business weren't enough, Richard (CJ Wilson), Hazel's successful plastic surgeon husband has a need for more meaningful adventures, which frequently takes him away to do more satisfying charitable work in disaster struck places like Haiti. These absences compound Hazel's tensions about being pregnant and on her own.

Richard's headstrong personality plus doctor's ego mentioned in the quote at the top of this review bring the play's fourth character into the picture: Annie (Lisa Joyce),a young Irish woman who Richard hired as a nanny without consulting his wife. While she seems like a fine candidate for the job, Hazel is understandably resentful to have a stranger arrive on her doorstep unannounced and without being consulted. Not a good start for either employer or employee!

While the play's second scene shows Hazel firmly determined to send Annie back to Ireland, she unsurprisingly does get to stay stay. Neither does it take a Sherlock Holmes to guess that the eager to please Nanny has her own dysfunctional history and that her presence is likely to bring the simmering tensions in this household to a full boil.

Joyce is excellent in revealing the yearnings and resentments beneath Annie's accommodating surface. However, both she and young Kelemen could work a bit harder on projecting more clearly.

No projection problems for CJ Wilson, however. He has a powerful voice that soars to the rafters, so that even someone with a hearing problem is unlikely to miss a word he utters. However, his Richard is such an unsympathetic, self-important character that you end up wishing you could shut him up. While Hazel is sensitive enough to be open to understanding the real cause of Daniel's troublesome behavior, Harris has left little room for Richard to come across as a genuinely good man if misguided as a husband and father.

Director Gaye Taylor Upchurch expertly oversees the escalating tensions. The production details are well handled by the designers, especially the scenes between the fifteen acts — some dimmed but with visible action, some blackouts.

I would have been even more impressed with Ms. Harris's ability to tell a basically familiar story affectingly if she could have avoided some rather glaringly overlooked reality checks. For instance, it's one thing to choose full time parenting but why in the world wouldn't someone in Hazel's financial circumstances have the sense to hire a house cleaner or house cleaning service to relieve her from those chores which have nothing to do with being a good or capable mom. And even stay-at-home, full-time moms who can't afford a nanny, will line up one or two reliable baby sitters for some time to themselves (which is something Hazel repeatedly says she desperately needs).

Finally, Hazel is still smart enough for her lawyer's training and caution to kick in when dealing with the unwanted nanny's legal rights. That makes it hard to believe that despite her emotional connection with the Italian woman whose product she plans to sell, it's unlikely that she would jump into a business she knows nothing about without some sort of research or a business plan.

My fussing about credibility gaps aside, I look forward to seeing more of this playwright's work.

Finally, as mentioned in my review of The Village Bike, opening on the same day as this one, this is the third British import by a woman playwright with different and yet similar agendas, seen in a two-week period.
Our New Girl by Nancy Harris
Directed by Gaye Taylor Upchurch
Cast: Lisa Joyce (Annie), Henry Kelemen (Daniel), Mary McCann (Hazel) and CJ Wilson (Richard)
Sxenic design by Timothy R. Mackabee
Costume design by Sarah J. Holden
Lighting design by David Weiner
Sound design by Stowe Nelson
Dialect Coach: Ben Furey
Stage Manager: Samantha Watson
Running Time: 2 hours with 1 intermission
Atlantic Stage 2, 330 West 16th Street
From 5/28/14; opening 6/10/14; closing 6/29/14
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Our New Girl
  • I disagree with the review of Our New Girl
  • The review made me eager to see Our New Girl
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted add to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter
Subscribe to our FREE email updates: E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message. If you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
The New Similes Dictionary
New Similes Dictionary

Slings & Arrows  cover of  new Blu-Ray cover
Slings & Arrows- view 1st episode free

Book Of Mormon MP4 Book of Mormon -CD
Our review of the show

©Copyright 2014, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from