The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings







Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review

You're going to have a child! Oh, my God in heaven, it's not true! — Honorine (Fanny's mother) Oh, Mama, It's true! — Fanny You dishonest girl! It's lucky your father's not alive — this would kill him— Honorine
l-r: Elena Shaddow and James Snyder
(Photo: Joan Marcus)
Fanny, the 1954 musical that Harold Rome, S.N. Behrman and Joshua Logan fashioned from Marcel Pagnol's film trilogy (Marius, 1931; Fanny, 1932; Cesar, 1936) was a huge hit when it opened on Broadway in 1954, chalking up 888 performances. For some inexplicable reason, it has been relegated to relative obscurity. The question is why?

Rome's near-operatic score is ambitious, melodic, lush and vibrant. The story of a pregnant girl, who weds a kindly and rich 70 year-old merchant when her sea-infatuated lover sails away, is, unlike many musicals, emotionally involving. It is the tender core of the story that comes to the fore in the admirable City Center's Encore presentation under the caressing direction of Marc Bruni. David Ives contributed a perfectly satisfactory concert version adaptation.

A film version minus Rome's songs (but with Rome's themes used as underscoring) follows a course that succeeded in its own right. But Rome's score is very special in that it is eminently worthy of its subject and vice versa. So let's praise the melodic and lyrical enhancement of the stage version that identifies the humorous and wise waterfront people for whom it was created. Musical director Rob Berman gives glorious support to instant winners like the title song, "Why Be Afraid to Dance," "Never Too Late for Love," "Welcome Home" and "Restless Heart."

Fanny is also that rare golden-era musical that makes us care what happens to its characters whose lives are to be bittersweetly intertwined (Marius's father the bar proprietor Cesar (George Hearn); the lonely, elderly sailmaker Panisse (Fred Applegate) who's enamored of Fanny; the passionate young lovers Marius (James Snyder) and Fanny (Elena Shaddow)). The story is foremost and plentiful. If there is a drawback, it is seeing these otherwise fine performers with script in hand, as is the custom in this series. Mr. Hearn seemed to rely on his more than the other principals.

To its glory, the singing, including that of the large ensemble chorus, is for the most part exceptional. I can't help it if echoes of Ezio Pinza's basso voice and accent still resonate in my brain, but Tony Award-winner (Sunset Boulevard, La Cage Aux Folles). Hearn's voice is nevertheless impressive and expressive in its own right, especially in Cesar's lilting "Love is a Very Light thing." Applegate, who earned laughs as the Blind Hermit in Young Frankenstein, endows Panisse with a notable joie de vivre but also a touch of poignancy with the sentimental "To My Wife."

The good-looking Snyder has a stirring tenor voice and he wowed the audience with the title song. Fanny couldn't have a more charming interpreter than Shaddow, whose bright soprano voice soars in the impassioned "I Have to Tell You." Priscilla Lopez, most recently seen in In the Heights, captures the lusty comical nature of Honorine, the fish stall keeper and Fanny's mother.

Choreographer Lorin Latarro has incorporated some lively dances for the wedding scene and plenty of acrobatics for the rousing and colorful "Cirqué Français" in Act II. I presume that Latarro gets credit for the insinuating wiggles and gyrations of the Belly Dancer as performed by Nina LaFarga. This is a particularly well-staged number that segues into a bar brawl among the bar's rough and horny habitués. Young Ted Sutherland was also standout with his sturdy singing and performance as Cesario the young son of Fanny and Marius.

Bruni, who has served as a directing associate on a number of Encore's productions, has mindfully put the relationships front and center. But with the help of John Lee Beatty as scenic consultant, he has also allowed the ambiance of life on the Marseille waterfront, with its vendors, sailors, fishermen and townspeople, to play a significant part in the action. Among the excellent scenic touches is the mast of a sailing ship that looms behind the large on stage orchestra. Interestingly, the Encore Series, in this age of scaled down musical revivals on the main stem, doesn't really seem scenically challenged anymore.

There is no denying that Fanny is a beautifully romantically conceived musical with a magnanimous heart. It deserves a higher place in the pantheon of distinguished American musical plays. By the time you read this you may have lost the short window of opportunity to enjoy its many and lasting pleasures. I understand that the original cast recording is out of print and difficult to find. Let's hope Encore! issues its own recording.

Book by S.N. Behrman and Joshua Logan (based on the Trilogy of Marcel Pagnol
Music and Lyrics by Harold Rome
Directed by Marc Bruni

Cast: David Patrick Kelly (The Admiral), James Snyder (Marius), Priscilla Lopez (Honorine), Elena Shaddow (Fanny), Rebecca Eichenberger) (Customer), Megan Sikora (Claudette), Shannon Lewis (Claudine), Fred Applegate (Panisse), George Hearn (Cesar), Michael McCormick (Escartifique), Jack Doyle (Burn), Nina La Farga (Belly Dancer), Martin Sola (Hakim), Grasan Kingsberry (Second Mate), Ted Sutherland (Cesario, Jay Lusteck (Louis).
Scenic Consultant: John Lee Beatty
Costume Consultant: Martin Pakledinaz
Lighting: Ken Billington
Sound: Scott Lehrer
Concert Adaptation: David Ives
Music Coordinator: Seymour red Press
Original Orchestrations: Philip J. Lang
Choreographer: Lorin Latarro
Music Director: Rob Berman
Running Time: 2 hours 15 minutes including intermission
New York City Center, 131 West 55th Street
Tickets ($25 - $95)
Opened 02/04/2010
Closed 02/07/2010
Review by Simon Saltzman based on matinee performance 02/06/2010
Musical Numbers
Act One
    Overture /The Orchestra Octopus Song /David Patrick Kelly Restless Heart /James Snyder and Men Never Too Late for Love /Fred Applegate and Ensemble The Cold-Cream Jar Song /Fred Applegate Reprise: Restless Heart /Elena Shaddow and James Snyder Why Be Afraid to Dance?/ George Hearn, James Snyder, Elena Shaddow, and Ensemble Reprise: Never Too Late for Love /Fred Applegate, George Hearn, and Priscilla Lopez Shika, Shika Nina Lafarga, Monica L. Patton, Martin Sola, and Ensemble Welcome Home/ George Hearn Like You /James Snyder and George Hearn Have to Tell You /Elena Shaddow Fanny /James Snyder and Elena Shaddow Montage /Ensemble Oysters, Cockles, and Mussels /Ensemble Panisse and Son /Fred Applegate Wedding Dance /Company Finale /Fred Applegate, Elena Shaddow, and Company
Act Two
    Entr'acte /The Orchestra Birthday Song /Company To My Wife/ Fred Applegate The Thought of You (Reprise: / Have to Tell You) /James Snyder and Elena Shaddow Love Is a Very Light Thing /George Hearn Reprise: Fanny (Other Hands, Other Hearts) /Elena Shaddow, George Hearn, and James Snyder Be Kind to Your Parents /Elena Shaddow and Ted Sutherland Cesario's Party (Cirque Franqais) /Circus Performers Reprise: The Cold-Cream Jar Song / Ensemble Reprise: Welcome Home /Fred Applegate, George Hearn, and Elena Shaddow
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Fanny
  • I disagree with the review of Fanny
  • The review made me eager to see Fanny
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

You can also contact us at Curtainup at Facebook , Curtainup at Twitter and at our Blog Annex
Subscribe to our FREE email updates with a note from editor Elyse Sommer about additions to the website -- with main page hot links to the latest features posted at our numerous locations. To subscribe, E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message -- if you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
South Pacific  Revival
South Pacific

In the Heights
In the Heights

Playbill Broadway Yearbook


©Copyright 2010, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from