The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings







Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review
The Singing Forest

I dream about . . .a forest. Made from the voices of all the creatures who will ever be born, have ever lived —Loï.
That's the whole dream?—Gray.
No, I . . .walk through their voices, every bit of life vibrating with the music of, the moans of the tortured — cries of death: keening, loss, we can't stop it, terror, we can't help but . . .in our coupling, in our birth, our days: a song. —Loë
Olympia Dukakis
(Photo: Carol Rosegg)
We all know that actors often works as waiters, bartenders and office temps to pay the rent in between acting gigs. But here's a new addition to the between-jobs possibilities: Stand-in psycho-therapy patient. You may not find this job opportunity on Craig's List, but you can see it at work in Craig Lucas's The Singing Forest now in its world premiere at the Public' Theater. The very appealing young actor playing this stand-in analysand, is Jonathan Groff who also appeared in Lucas's Prayer For My Daughter as well as Spring Awakening and Hair in Central Park.

Oskar Eustis, the artistic director of the Public Theater, has this to say about Lucas's new play: "The terrible, only partially reparable wounds of history and the equally vexing problems of our individual traumas are the stuff of this unlikely comedy." The Holocaust is indeed not a historic event easily translated into a comedy. Yet, Lucas, an unfailingly interesting playwright and adapter (he adapted Elizabeth Spenscr's novella for the musical, Light in the Piazza), has managed to do just that. He not only examines the events of the thirties via a family saga and through a comic lens, but veers into a four-door farce to reconnect the long and purposely out-of-touch Riemans and the people coincidentally involved with them.

Like the lives it depicts, The Singing Forest is messy, sprawling play. It's top heavy with credibility challenging coincidences and in need of trimming. But, while it's a play that will have you walking out a touch unsure whether you really loved and understood what you saw, you won't be bored watching it and you'll probably find yourself thinking about it after you leave..

For one thing, attention must and will be paid, if only to figure what's going on and who's really infuriated with who, and why. Then there's Olympia Dukakis as the locus of the Rieman family's dysfunction. This is her most unique role since the TV mini-series Tales of the City. She may be the focal character, but this is an ensemble play and Dukakis is supported by eight eminently watchable actors, each of whom play two roles. That adds up to a total of seventeen intriguing personalities, which include Dr. Sigmund Freud and his daughter Anna.

The program indicates that the three acts are neatly divided between three different locales and time frames: New York in 2000, Vienna from 1933 and 1938, and London in 1940. However, this is not your conventional two-intermission play. Thus, with the help of some location defining roll-on props, John McDermott's overall scenic design — a rather ugly but effective affair with sliding panels — serves all locations.

The play entwines a number of subplots and themes into an intricate plot arc. Since the Riemans are Viennese Jews whose Jewish identity went into hiding years ago, it took the Nazi rise to power to flush out their Jewish roots and Loë's brother Walter's homosexuality.

Having given up their religion, the Riemans found a new God in Sigmund Freud. No wonder that the cast of characters is studded with analysts and analysands. The analysands include the analysts themselves and of course Jonathan Groff's charmingly conflicted Gray, the unemployed actor who's a stand-in for a rich Arab-American member of the Rieman family tree (Louis Cancelmi). As it turns out, his offbeat job has him learn more about himself than his employer. Groff and Calcemi also play the more serious parts of young Walter Rieman and his lover in the Vienna scenes,

While Dr. Oliver Pfaff (Mark Blum, who also appears as the head of the assimilated Riemans in Vienna) is a traditional chair-behind-couch practitioner of Freud's trade. The now white-haired and reclusive mother (Dukakis) whom he hasn't seen for thirty-five years is also a therapist, but her current modus operandi is not the kind covered by any insurance plan.

A separate and yet connected sub-plot revolves around the competition for Gray (Groff) — Pfaff wants him as a patient, Shar Unger (Rob Campbell), the therapist he's supervising, would prefer to have him as a lover. Other plot threads involve Gray's girl friend Beth (Susan Pourfar, who doubles as the young Loë) and her Starbucks co-worker Lazlo (Randy Harrison, very funny in the New York scenes and scary as a Nazi in the Vienna circa 1938 flashback). And yes, Lazlo is also closely connected to the two shrinks.

To further complicate matters there's Bertha Ahmad (Deborah Offner), who's estranged from both her son (Cancelmi) and her mother (Dukakis who at one point, and not without reason, describes her as "Clytemnestra. Husband Killer".).

Since every self-respecting epic must have a wise old drunk, we also have Bill (Pierre Epstein, who also has the more distinguished role of Dr. Freud). Bill befriends Loë in Starbucks, the place where coincidence sends practically everyone at one point or another.

If all this sounds like a knotty tangle of psyches gone amuk, hold on. The best part of the play is when everyone converges on Loë's Staten Island loft (yes, Staten Island!) and the comedy switches gears to become a full-scale door-slamming farce.

I'm still not sure why Lucas chose to build a play on a foundation of coincidences and I was somewhat let down to see that brilliant farcical mid-section followed by a finale that tries to put all the pieces of this Freudian puzzle together. After all, one's personal history can never really be neatly summed up. It just keeps happening.

The Singing Forest
Written by Craig Lucas
Directed by Mark Wing-Davey
Cast: Mark Blum (Dr. Oliver Pfaff, Martin Rieman), Rob Campbell (Shar Unger, Max Schur), Louis Cancelmi (Jules Ahmad, Simon Hirsch), Olympia Dukakis (Loë Rieman), Pierre Epstein (/Bill, Sigmund Freud), Jonathan Groff (Gray Koranskyi, Walter Rieman), Randy Harrison (Lazlo Fickes, Gerhard Zeizler), Deborah Offner (Bertha Ahmad, Anna Freud), and Susan Pourfar (Beth Adler, Young Loë)
Scenic design: John McDermott
Costume design: Gabriel Berry
Lighting design: Japhy Weideman
Original music and sound design: John Gromada
Stage Manager: Zac Chandler
Running Time: 2 hours and 45 minutes, with 2 intermissions
Public Theater 420 Lafayette Street
From 4/07/09; opening 4/27/09; closing 5/17/09. Reviewed by Elyse Someer at April 24th press performance
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of The Singing Forest
  • I disagree with the review of The Singing Forest
  • The review made me eager to see The Singing Forest
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

You can also contact us at Curtainup at Facebook or Curtainup at Twitter
Try for great seats to
Jersey Boys
The Little Mermaid
Lion King
Shrek The Musical

South Pacific  Revival
South Pacific

In the Heights
In the Heights

Playbill 2007-08 Yearbook

Leonard Maltin's Classic Movie Guide
Leonard Maltin's 2008 Movie Guide


©Copyright 2009, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from