The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings





Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants









Free Updates
Writing for Us
A CurtainUp Berkshires Review

A Rat in the Skull

I'm a Londoner mate, and I resent what basically a quarrel between two brands of Paddy [Irish} has done to my town, my life, both as a copper trying to do his job and as an ordinary f---ing human being.
--- Detective Superintendent Harris of the London Metropolitan Police.
Cranwell Resort

The Porches Inn

Rat In Skull cast
front to back: Michael Crane, Phil Burke and Jonathan Epstein
(Photo:Kenneth Sprague)
Plays written in response to specific historic situations tend to evoke different responses with the passing of time. A case in point: A Rat in the Skull, Ron Hutchinson's drama involving three law enforcement officers (two Brits, an Irish Protestant with the Royal Ulster Constabulary and an IRA (Irish Republican Army) terrorist in custody after a London a bombing).

Hutchinson's four characters represent the factions in the protracted violence that erupted into numerous bombings and civilian casualties. Shaped as a police interrogation drama but with more lengthy monologues than the action typical for the genre, Rat premiered in 1984 at The Royal Court Theatre in London -- twelve years after Sunday, Bloody Sunday (the Civil Rights parade that led to a period of strife and bloodshed that made "The Troubles" an international media event); a year before an Anglo-Irish Agreement was signed and fourteen years before the Belfast Agreement.

The opening of Berkshire Theatre Festival's revival eerily coincided with news of a second bombing attempt in London, just two weeks after more than fifty Londoners were killed in subway and bus explosions set off by suicide bombers -- even though an estimated 4.2 million closed circuit television cameras are installed across Britain and the average Briton crosses the line of sight of a security camera an estimated 300 times each day. This unanticipated timing works both for and against this production's resonance.

To some, the return to a period when the headlines about the unsettling conflict in Northern Ireland will seem timelier than ever in view of our current issues with terrorism. Others will see it as a case of art overshadowed by real life. Though religion was also a factor for terrorists like Rat in the Skull's Roche and horrendous as their bombings were, Mr. Hutchinson's faction can't possibly have the gut-level impact of facing the very real fallout from the zealotry of today's suicide bombers. The large, lit-up photos of the captured terrorist leave no doubt as to the "expert tactics" employed by Nelson, the Northern Ireland Constabulary who's been called in to hasten a confession. There's also little doubt that Roche, the terrorist, is guilty. The real investigation is into into the long-standing attitudes (the rat in each man's skull! ) that have scarred both these opposite sides of the fence Irishmen (Nelson's wounds being less visible but even more complex than Roche's) and that have made the British "coppers" mistrust and disdain all "Paddies" or Irishmen. t

The projected images of Roche seem tame in comparison to prisoner abuse images and news stories about Americans actually mistreating political prisoners or " outsourcing" such investigations to countries without qualms about torture. Still, the playwright's take on the darker side of the Northern Irish "Troubles" draws a powerful group portrait of four men symbolizing all viewpoints. Rat in the Skull is not an easy play to watch, not just because of its darkness, but because the accents (especially Roche's) make much of the passionate language and furious humor hard to grasp and the extended monologues quite taxing.

Whether this twenty-year-old play strikes you as more or less relevant than ever, you've got to admire Berkshire Theatre Festival for tackling serious plays in an environment normally associated with lighter, more uplifting summer entertainment -- as well as invariably bringing an excellent team aboard for a thoroughly professional production.

Jonathan Epstein actually played Detective Inspector Nelson eighteen years ago in Boston, under the direction of Tina Packer of whose Shakespeare & Company he was long a stellar member. He brings more of a mature and wry melancholy than menace to the personally and politically troubled Nelson. It's a compelling performance that would be even more so if director Dennis Garnhum had persuaded him to tone down the decibel level of his rage. Epstein has a fine, fiery sparring partner in Phil Burke.

Malcom Ingram whose work, like Epstein's, is familiar from his many years at Shakespeare & Company, portrays Superintendent Harris as the very model of a jaded bureaucrat. The casting directors at the BBC ought to check out Mr. Ingram next time they're looking for a lead for one of their terrific detective series.

Alexander Dodge has transformed the Unicorn stage into a metaphoric boxing ring. That ring, a raised mesh platform surrounded by the debris left in the wake of the bombing being investigated, is strikingly lit from beneath by lighting designer Matthew E. Adelson. Ultimately, I found the staging uniformly satisfying but the playwright, director and actors' efforts to keep me tensely riveted to my seat only sporadically successful.

Playwright:Ron Hutchinson
Director: Dennis Garnhum
Cast: Phil Burke (Roche), Michael Crane (Constable Naylor), Jonathan Epstein (Inspector Nelson), Malcolm Ingram (Superintendent Harris)
Set Design: Alexander Dodge
Costume Design: Branimira Ivanova
Lighting Designer: Matthew E. Adelson
Composer and Sound Designer: Scott Killian
Berkshire Theatre Festival Unicorn Theatre, Stockbridge, 413-298-5576 or
July 20 to August 6, 2005; opening July 21st
Monday through Saturday evenings at 8pm, and Saturday matinees on July 30 and August 6 at 2pm.
Tickets: $37 to $42. Students with proper ID receive 50 percent discount.
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer based on July 21st performance

deb and harry's wonderful things -  crafts .  yarns

tales from shakespeare
Retold by Tina Packer of Shakespeare & Co.
Click image to buy.
Our Review

Berkshire Hikes Book Cover
Berkshire Hikes &

The Berkshire Book

metaphors dictionary cover
6,500 Comparative Phrases including 800 Shakespearean Metaphors by CurtainUp's editor.
Click image to buy.
Go here for details and larger image.

©Copyright 2005, Elyse Sommer, CurtainUp.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from
Berkshire Theatre Festival