The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings





Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants









Free Updates
Writing for Us
A CurtainUp Review
The Pursuit of Persephone

By Elyse Sommer

A great seething anthill was the Triangle Club. It gave a musical comedy every year, traveling with cast, chorus, orchestra, and scenery all through the Christmas vacation. The play and the music were the work of undergraduates, and the club itself was the most influential of institutions, over three hundred men competing for it every year,
--- F. Scott Fitzgerald, This Side of Paradise.

In 1913 a young Midwestern Princeton undergraduate named F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote his first show for the famous Triangle Club. He also fell in love with a debutante named Ginevra King. Though Ginevra proved to be forever beyond his reach some might argue that he didn't really lose her since she became his role model for Daisy Buchanan in The Great Gatsby and her side of their two-year correspondence saw life in the pages of some of his short stories.

The whole cliquish Ivy League social scene on the cusp of World War One inspired Fitzgerald's This Side of Paradise. Now, more than ninety years later, Carla Reichel and Peter Mills, whose own romantic and professional partnership began in 1993 when they were both Princeton undergraduates and members of the still existent Triangle Club, have turned Fitzgerald's college years into a musical. The collaborative venture, directed by Reichel and written with composer and lyricist Mills, takes its title, The Pursuit of Persephone, from that first Fitzgerald show for the Triangle Club, In Pursuit of Priscilla.

Under the auspices of Prospect Theater Company, of which Reichel is artistic director, Persephone's debut is a quite lavishly staged showcase that anyone with an interest in musically rich, smartly constructed, original musical theater should see before this limited run ends. As with any first public airing, there are some problems, most a case of too much of a good thing, but none that couldn't be fixed with editing.

As stated in the program's notes, the creative duo's chief aim was to "to capture the sense of the ephemeral nature of youth and passion." They have been true to that aim and in so doing have brought Fitzgerald and his Princeton friends to vivid life -- especially his best buddies Edmund Wilson and John Peale Bishop who also achieved considerable renown, Wilson as a critic and Bishop as a poet. (Bishop's poems included an elegy to Fitzgerald entitled "The Hours." Those familiar with Fitzgerald's work and life story, will also recognize ideas that dominated his writing taking shape. The music beautifully reflects the spirit and flavor of the period with a fine mix of ballads, novelty numbers for solos, duet and ensembles to move the story forward.

The story begins in Hollywood in 1937, with an older, recently off the wagon Fitzgerald. The famous wild times with his wife, the beautiful but mentally unstable Zelda, and his best work behind him. He's now unhappily employed as a screenwriter. With Zelda institutionalized and his old flame Ginevra recently divorced, he's asked her to meet him in the lounge of a Hollywood Hotel where the bartender in a witty bit of double casting is his erstwhile rival for her affections. This set-up is the device for dramatizing his remembrances of being a small town outsider eager to widen his horizons by becoming an Ivy League insider and winning the season's top debutante.

While the nineteen-year-old Fitzgerald takes front and center stage, his older persona continues to hover around the edges of the remembered scenes, and several times breaking into songs -- notably, a beautiful solo, "Paradise for Now" in Act One and "I Could Never Let You Go", a lovely shadow duet with the young Scott near the end.

The remembered scenes include Triangle Club excerpts and a football number which are great fun. However, it's the Princeton razzle dazzle stuff that would benefit most from trimming.

Reichel has managed to assemble a large (twenty in all) talented cast. Chris Fuller is a charming Scott (he actually looks a little like the real Fitzgerald) and Jessica Grové is a pert and pretty as his elusive love. The fact that Fuller and Daniel Yates, his older alter ego, don't resemble each other at all doesn't matter, especially since Yates is the show's most powerful singer and a splendid actor. Special bravos are also due to David Abeles as Edmund Wilson and Piper Goodeve as his romantic interest, and Ginevra's finishing school roommate (a Mills/Reichel invented character).

Sidney Shannon's costumes add to the show's visual pleasures. While Daniel Feyer's excellent little orchestra is positioned to the side and well above the stage, with a curtain to presumable soften the sound, it nevertheless is often too loud to prevent the lyrics from getting lost. Perhaps a brass instrument less and an extra violin would alleviate this problem in future productions. If Persephone has the continued life it deserves, I hope it will include the choreography by Tesha Buss, whose talent, like Mills and Reichel's is Broadway worthy.

The Pursuit of Persephone could use a more descriptive, less vaguely highbrow sounding title (shades of The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee), but make no mistake about it— this is an intelligent, well-crafted book musical that's continuously melodic, not operatic, and highly entertaining. At $15 a ticket, it's also the best buy in town.

Ilyria, another Mills/Reichel collaboration, reviewed at CurtainUp at the New Jersey Shakespeare Theater.

The Pursuit of Persephone
Music and Lyrics: Peter Mills
Book by Peter Mills and Cara Reichel, based on F. Scott Fitzgerald's This Side of Paradise
Directed by Cara Reichel
Cast of Characters
The Big Five:Chris Fuller (F. Scott Fitzgerald),David Abeles (Edmund Wilson), Benjamin Sands (John Peale Bishop), Piper Goodeve (Marie Hersey),(Jessica Grove (Ginevra King)
Grown-Ups: Daniel Yates (Older Scott), Dennis Holland (Dean Donegan), Jaye Maynard (Mrs. King, Chanteuse) College Boys: William Brock, Matt Gibson, Maclain Looper, Brandon Parrish, Dominic Roberts, Paul A. Schaefer, Courter Simmons, Robby Sharpe
Debutantes: Cheryl Dowling, Shannon McShane, Julie Lachance,Melissa Robinette
Scenic Concepts: Mimothy Mackabee & Cara Reichel
Costume Design: Sidney Shannon
Lighting Design: Jiyoun Chang
Properties: Stephanie Wiesner
Assistant Director & Dramaturg: Elyzabeth Gorman
Orchestrations: Daniel Feyer (also music director) & Peter Mills
Choreography: Tesha Buss
ORCHESTRA: Piano/Conductor -- Daniel Feyer; Flute/Clarinet/Tenor Sax-- Eric Kay;Flute/Clarinet/Alto Sax -- Tom Piercy; Trumpet-- Andre Canniere; Trombone -- Eric Beilucei; Violin -- Yury Shubov; Bass-- Matt Seharfglass; Drums --Alexander Rea
Running time: 2 1/2 hours includingintermission.
Prospect Theater Company at the Connelly Theatre, 220 E. 4th St., 212-352-3101
From 4/30/05 to 5/22/05
Thursdays through Saturdays at 8PM, Sundays at 3PM
Tickets: $15 for adults and $12 for students

Reviewed by Elyse Sommer based on May 5th performance
Musical Numbers
Act One
  • No One Wants the Show to Go/ Chanteuse, Scott, Triangle Boys
  • Down the Track/ Scott
  • Minnesota / Clive, Wilton, Tom
  • To Beat the Band / Ginevra, Partygoers
  • To Beat the Band (Reprise) / Scott
  • Princeton Lives in You / Older Scott, Triangle Boys
  • Class/ Scott, Edmund, J.P.
  • Letters to Boys / Marie, Ginevra, Debutantes
  • If Only/ J.P., Scott
  • The Black Ball/ Scott, Cottage Members
  • Aught Two / Clive, Freddy, Tom
  • A Place Apart / J.P.
  • Paradise for Now/ Older Scott
  • Let's Don't / Edmund, Marie
  • Act I Finale / Ensemble
Act Two
  • A Trip to the Seaside/ Ham, Ellis, Scott, Trip, Triangle Boys, Jersey Girls
  • Invitation / Ginevra
  • Oh, de Rich is Different/ Ham, Trip, Ellis
  • Improvising / Scott, Ginevra
  • The Blue Slip / Dean Donegan, Slip Girls, J.P., Ginevra, Scott, Clive
  • Fight Songs / Scott, Tyler, Football Fans
  • Poseidon Myself / Edmund
  • Half and Half/ Clive, Ham, Freddy, Tom
  • I Could Never Let You Go / Scott, Older Scott
  • Consolation / Marie
  • Les Jeunes Filles--Finale / Freddy, Trip, Tom, Scott, Triangle Boys
Broadway Musicals: The 101 Greatest Shows of All Time
Easy-on-the budget super gift for yourself and your musical loving friends. Tons of gorgeous pictures.

Tales From Shakespeare
Retold by Tina Packer of Shakespeare & Co.
Click image to buy.
Our Review

At This Theater Cover
At This Theater

Leonard Maltin's 2005 Movie Guide
Leonard Maltin's 2005 Movie Guide

Ridiculous! The Theatrical Life and Times of Charles Ludlam
Ridiculous!The Theatrical Life & Times of Charles Ludlam

metaphors dictionary cover
6, 500 Comparative Phrases including 800 Shakespearean Metaphors by CurtainUp's editor.
Click image to buy.
Go here for details and larger image.


©Copyright 2005, Elyse Sommer, CurtainUp.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from