BOOKS and CDs
LETTERS TO EDITOR
A CurtainUp London Review
by Lizzie Loveridge
The Madness music is both its strength and its weakness. The relentless beat, compulsive at first, becomes too samey to sustain musicality for the best part of three hours. Although two songs have been specially written for the musical, more contrast is needed in the form of ballads or slower numbers or even something more melodic and less relentlessly head banging. The opening number convinces that this is basic, unsophisticated FUN but this laddish musical is "in yer face, and full on" to the point where it will make you feel old beyond your years.
Add the convoluted story line which apes that other British musical hit Blood Brothers (about twins brought up differently), of a pivotal moment deciding two parallel lives, and the realisation that each scene has to be duplicated for both "good outcome" and "bad outcome" sinks in with numbing consequences to both butt and brain. The credibility of some of the story lines is poor. What loving son would agree to his mother's house being set on fire, even if she was meant to be out for the evening? The other problem is that this musical is set now and not in the 1980s which is bizarre because Madness' music was so distinctively 1980s.
There were patently lots of good ideas but this show is severely in need of some censorship. Like a cake with every possible flavour and colour of frosting, Our House is in need of some editing of the ingredients to make it more palatable. There were three scenes set in Borstal or prison, each conceived well, with great design, but altogether, too many. I loved the back projection of the roller coaster which was like a virtual ride and the scenes featuring the disintegrating Morris Minor car. There are dances in Camden Market cleverly aping the market traders from Oliver! and My Fair Lady, "Who will buy my cannabis?". There is plenty of local atmosphere and scenes of London life, including Joe's parents' meeting at the popular seaside resort of Margate.
The young cast work exceptionally hard and I can fault none of them. Michael Jibson gives value for money as he plays both versions of Joe Casey, Good Joe in white suit, Bad Joe in Black suit. Julia Gay plays his girlfriend Sarah and has a sweet voice. The choreography relies on raw energy but has some original moves including a kicking thigh dance from prone dancers. Ian Reddington works hard as a ghostly dead Dad trying to steer his son on the path he did not take.
What starts as dynamic, too soon becomes insensitive, crude, teeth jarring to the point where you need four Nurofen, two for your headache and two to shove in your ears as temporary ear plugs. It is a shame because with judicious cuts Our House could have been so much better. Sometimes less is more.
6, 500 Comparative Phrases including 800 Shakespearean Metaphors by CurtainUp's editor.
Click image to buy.
Go here for details and larger image.