The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings





Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants









Free Updates
Writing for Us
A CurtainUpLondon Review
Mary Poppins
by Lizzie Loveridge

I'm practically perfect in every way!
--- Mary Poppins
Mary Poppins
Sweep Scene
(Photo: Michael le Poer Trench from the website

I didn't expect the new musical of Mary Poppins to be quite so good as it is. I suppose I might have dismissed it as another musical tapping into the children's market a la Chitty Chitty Bang Bang which I dutifully went to see as a theatre critic rather than out of choice. Wrong, wrong! This production of Mary Poppins which Cameron Mackintosh tells us in the programme has been twenty five years in the planning is as crisp and quirky and delightful as its eponymous heroine. Of course its pedigree is practically perfect: Richard Eyre, once Artistic Director of the National Theatre directing. Co-directing and choreographing, and I think with a hand in the design, is Matthew Bourne, darling of the dance, stylish choreographer with a charmed life whose ballets have spellbound the most obdurate of anti-dance patrons.

Actor turned writer, Julian Fellowes has updated the story concentrating on the dysfunction of the Banks family incorporating more of PL Travers' book material than in the Disney film. Mr Banks (David Haig) is a banker with a penchant for figures but with no emotional intelligence with which to nurture his wife Winifred (Linzi Hateley) nor their two children, Jane (Nicola Bowman, Carrie Fletcher, Poppy Lee Friar, Charlotte Spencer, Faye Spittlehouse) and Michael (Jake Caterall, Perry Millward, Harry Stott, Ben Watton). Instead he is critical and a real wet blanket; his behaviour to his wife verges on bullying. Only when we meet his old nanny, Miss Andrew (Rosemary Ashe), who arrives with bottled supplies of Brimstone and Treacle, do we understand why. Mary Poppins (Laura Michelle Kelly) suddenly appears in response to an advertisement that the children want to place for a new Nanny. She instantly understands the needs of the whole family and sets about instilling a benevolent order.

Mary Poppins is set in an Edwardian London, a London of contrasts, of class division, where coal is used for heating and chimney sweeps are part of that underclass fuelling society. Mary Poppins takes a pair of bored children and teaches them to enjoy the parks of London, the street markets culminating in the joyous "Step in Time" tap dancing number where all the chimney sweeps dance silhouetted on the smoky rooftops of the city. "Feed the Birds" is a soulful, pretty song sung by an old, poor woman (Julia Sutton) to contrast with the moneymaking business of the City.

The Banks' house is designed with an eye for detail, sliding to reveal a large ground floor with open staircase, a spacious well equipped kitchen and the children's nursery in the attic where Mary Poppins opens her carpet bag and brings out everything from a bedspread with bed to a hat stand and full length mirror. The main set is like a dolls' house, fussy and Victorian fully stuffed. The sets are real, not computer generated images and all the better for it. In the park when the statues magically come to life I could see Matthew Bourne's influence, their stone encrusted costumes overhung with ivy. The park set starts with massive green grey trunks of trees but as the statues come to life there is a lighting shift with things getting brighter and brighter as the children learn to appreciate their environment.

In the black and white bank set where Mr Banks works, the clerks are drawn on the pillars as Dickensian-like, they sit on high stools and scratch away with quill pens. The sweetie stall which is the setting for the big hit "Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious" is colourful, gorgeous and extravagant reminding me of Bourne's Nutcracker. A new song, "Temper, Temper" in the nursery has the sinister Edwardian dolls coming to life brimming with resentment in their calico stuffed costumes led by the delightful Valentine (Nathan Taylor) and recalling Shockheaded Peter.

It will of course take time for the new songs from the British writing team of George Stiles and Anthony Drewe, responsible for the award winning Honk!, to be as well known as the firm film favourites, "Chim Chim Cher-ee", "A Spoonful of Sugar" and " Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious" but "Practically Perfect" is one which we all came out humming on the night.

Laura Michelle Kelly is a treat. She has this wonderful presence, totally in control but with a quietly amused smile. Her first words to Michael as he stands there open-mouthed, like the audience wondering how Mary Poppins appeared onstage, "Shut your mouth. We are not a cod fish, Michael.". She is mysterious and enigmatic, gentle and fair, witty and everyone's favourite. Her costume changes are like her, colourful but keeping to the same shape, the Edwardian frock coat reinventing itself in red and blue and purple with the same straw hat with parrot handled umbrella. David Haig agonises as the distressed Mr Banks, he has a capacity for woeful speeches and a dejected air but we still warm to him. Gavin Lee is in fine voice as Bert, the chirpy Cockney support. There is comedy from Robertson Ay (Gerard Carey) the accident prone boot boy and Mrs Brill (Jenny Galloway) the grumpy cook-housekeeper. They are a strong ensemble cast with thoroughly professional performances throughout and the children are very good indeed. Eyre can be justifiably proud at some splendid casting. In the final few moments, true to the London Peter Pan tradition, Mary Poppins flies up to the circle and disappears as mysteriously as she appeared. I think this Mary Poppins will be reappearing on the London stage for some time.
Mary Poppins
Original Music and Lyrics by Richard M Sherman and Robert B Sherman
New songs and additional music and lyrics by George Stiles and Antony Drewe
Book by Julian Fellowes
Based on the stories of PL Travers and the Walt Disney film
Directed by Richard Eyre

Starring: Laura Michelle Kelly, Gavin Lee, David Haig, Linzi Hateley
With: Nicola Bowman/Carrie Fletcher/Poppy Lee Friar/Charlotte Spencer/Faye Spittlehouse, Jake Caterall/Perry Millward/Harry Stott/Ben Watton, Louisa Shaw, Tim Morgan, Claire Machin, Ian Burford, Jenny Gallloway, Gerard Carey, Kevin Williams, Stuart Neal, Alan Vicary, Nathna Taylor, Rosemary Ashe, Julia Sutton, Melanie La Barry, Savannah Stevenson, Poppy Tierney, Terel Nugent
Co-director and Choreographer: Matthew Bourne
Co-choreographer: Stephen Mear
Scenic and Costume Designer: Bob Crowley
Musical Supervisor: David Caddick
Musical Director: Nick Davies
Orchestrations: William David Brohn
Lighting Designer: Howard Harrison
Sound: Andrew Bruce
Co-created by Cameron Mackintosh
Produced for Disney Theatrical Productions by Thomas Schumacher
Running time: Three hours ten minutes with one interval
Box Office: 0870 850 9191
Booking to 24th September 2005.
Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge based on 16th December 2004 performance at the Prince Edward Old Compton Street London W1 (Tube: Leicester Square)
Musical Numbers
*New Songs
Act One
  • Chim Chim Cher-ee/Bert
  • *Cherry Tree Lane Part 1/George and Winifred Banks, Jane and Michael, Mrs Brill and Robertson Ay
    The Perfect Nanny/Jane and Michael
  • Cherry Tree Lane Part 2/George and Winifred Banks, Jane and Michael, Mrs Brill and Robertson Ay
  • *Practically Perfect/Mary Poppins, Jane and Michael
  • Jolly Holiday/Bert, Mary Poppins, Jane, Michael, Neleus and the Statues
  • Cherry Tree Lane (Reprise)/*Being Mrs Banks/Jolly Holiday (Reprise)/ George, Winifred, Jane and Michael
  • A Spoonful of Sugar/Mary Poppins, Jane, Michael, Robertson Ay and Winifred
  • Precision and Order/The Chairman and the Bank Clerks
  • A Man Has Dreams/George Banks
  • Feed the Birds/George Banks
  • Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious/Mary Poppins, Mrs Corry, Bert, Jane, Michael, Fannie, Annie and Customers
  • *Temper, Temper/Valentine, William, Mr Punch, the Doll and other Toys
  • Chim, Chim, Cher-ee (Reprise)/Bert and Mary Poppins
  • Act Two
  • Cherry Tree Lane (Reprise)/Mrs Brill, Michael, Jane, Winifred, Robertson Ay and George
  • *Brimstone and Treacle Part 1/Miss Andrew
  • Let's Go Fly a Kite/Bert, Park Keeper, Jane and Michael
  • *Good For Nothing/George
  • Being Mrs Banks (Reprise)/Winifred
  • *Brimstone and Treacle Part 2/Mary Poppins And Miss Andrew
  • Practically Perfect (Reprise)/Jane and Michael and Mary Poppins
  • Chim Chim Cher-ee (Reprise)/Bert
  • Step in Time/Bert, Mary Poppins, Jane Michael and the Sweeps
  • A Man Has Dreams/A Spoonful of Sugar (Reprise)/George and Bert
  • *Anything Can Happen/Jane and Michael, Mary Poppins, and the entire Company
  • A Spoonful of Sugar (Reprise)/Mary Poppins
  • A Shooting Star/The Orchestra
  • London Theatre Tickets
    Lion King Tickets
    Billy Elliot Tickets
    Mary Poppins Tickets
    Mamma Mia Tickets
    We Will Rock You Tickets
    Theatre Tickets

    Premium Tickets to
    Mary Poppins on Broadway

    London Theatre Walks

    Mendes at the Donmar
    Our Review

    Peter Ackroyd's  History of London: The Biography
    Peter Ackroyd's History of London: The Biography

    London Sketchbook
    London Sketchbook

    Tales From Shakespeare
    Retold by Tina Packer of Shakespeare & Co. Click image to buy.
    Our Review

    metaphors dictionary cover
    6, 500 Comparative Phrases including 800 Shakespearean Metaphors by CurtainUp's editor.
    Click image to buy.
    Go here for details and larger image.

    ©Copyright 2005, Elyse Sommer, CurtainUp.
    Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from