The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings


SEARCH CurtainUp



Etcetera and
Short Term Listings



LA/San Diego






Free Updates
NYC Weather
A CurtainUp Review

Ears On a Beatle

Ears On a Beatle Now Off-Broadway
Dan Lauria & Bill Dawes
Dan Lauria & Bill Dawes (Photo: Carol Rosegg)
Dan Lauria and Bill Dawes terrific portrayals of FBI Agents Howard Ballantine and Daniel McClure helped to make Ears On a Beatle one of the hits of last summer's Berkshire season. Now that the play has become part of the bustling Union Square theater scene, it's nice to report that Lauria and Dawes once again play the likeable snoops keeping tabs on "The Subject" who happens to be John Lennon.

If the playwright has made any major changes to the script, they are minor enough to let my original review apply to the current production, even though real time events have worked against this being a really satisfying transfer. You see, while the play resonated with some timeliness last summer, intervening events make Mr. St. Germain appear to be trying too hard and obviously to tie this story to what we've been seeing and hearing about the CIA and FBI and government officials being in or "out of the loop."

Eric Renschler has transferred his clever scenic design to fit the DR2's stage which is even smaller than the one in Sheffield, and is a proscenium rather than three-sided thrust configuration. The walls of file boxes are now angled but they still turn out to be not quite what they seem and serve as an apt visual metaphor that the FBI's scecret files are infinite. (The Lenon files, all but ten of which were released in 1995, are on display in this lobby as they were at Barrington Stage). The desks and park benches, which are the only other scenic props, are now moved on and off stage much more smoothly and quietly.

Berkshire natives and visitors will again have a first look at a St. Germain play, The God Committee. In anticipation of a larger audience, it will be at the company's Main Stage from July 22nd to August 7th.

Ears On A Beatle
Written and directed by Mark St. Germain
Cast: Dan Lauria, Bill Dawes. Voiceovers: Dick Cavett; Leon Wildes, Arlo Guthrie; Robert Vaughn; Geraldine Ferraro, Fred Savage
Sets: Eric Renschler
Costumes:David C. Woolard
Lighting Design: Daniel Ordower
Sound Design: Randy Hansen
Projections: Carl Casellla
Running Time: 90 Minutes, without an intermission
DR2, 103 E. 15th St. 212/239-6200
Tues through Fridays 8pm, Saturdays at 2 and 8pm, Sundays at 2 and 7pm
Tickets: $40
From 3/16/04 to 6/20/04; opening 3/28/04.
Re-reviewed by Elyse Sommer based on March 24th performance

Review of Ears On a Beatle During its Barrington Stage Premiere ---
By Elyse Sommer

The "ears" of the title belong to jaded, middle-aged FBI agent Howard Ballantine (Dan Lauria) and his novice assistant Daniel McClure (Bill Dawes). The "beatle" on whom their ears, eyes and surveillance bugs are trained is John Lennon, the rock star whose music and persona fired up a whole generation of young peace and love dedicated idealists.

While Ballantine and McClure are playwright Mark St. Germain's inventions, their surveillance of Lennon and his wife Yoko Ono is based on the now well-known fact that Lennon's love-and-peace message was sufficiently threatening to the politically conservative Nixon's administration to build up a secret file aimed at deporting Lennon for fear that his influence would affect the newly enfranchised voters and Lennon devotees. Thus Ears On a Beatle, which is being given its world premiere at Barrington Stage's smaller venue, is a docu-drama carved from a true chapter in American history that nowadays strikes some painfully familiar notes.

Fortunately, Mr. St. Germain is a good enough playwright not to rely solely on his source material (Barrington Stage audiences are invited to view copies of the now declassified FBI files on display in the lobby). Instead he has given the two agents intriguing back stories and has integrated them skillfully with historical information that spans nine years, from December 1971 (when Lennon and Yoko Ono moved to New York) to December 1980 (when Lennon was shot in front of his home in the Dakota apartment house). What's more, despite raising numerous weighty issues (civil liberties, privacy, abortion) and illustrating the corrosive effect of working within a deceitful system on McClure as well as Ballantine, the ninety-minute intermissionless play gallops along entertainingly and with a good deal of humor.

As Lennon was as much a sociological as a musical icon, the two agents' relationship is more than the usual police buddy set-up. The chemistry between the actors is potent, as are their individual performances.

Dan Lauria's marvelously rounded portrayal of Ballantine makes it easy to see something of his young apprentice in the rumpled and grown immune to idealism senior agent. A monologue that alone is worth the price of admission has Ballantine detailing how he, disguised as a telephone repairman pretending to check Lennon's phone for bugging devices (which have indeed been installed by the FBI), ended up breaking the unbreakable rule of never personalizing a subject. He refuses Lennon's offer for a cup of tea, but accepts a beer -- and comes away a fan and with an autograph for his teenaged daughter. This the man who hates one of his hit songs, "Imagine", because "it's like he wrote it in finger paint."

Bill Dawes (whose work, unlike Lauria's, I'm familiar with is equally impressive in depicting McClure, the golden boy who has joined the FBI because he loves his country but as an alternative to following his brother into the army to please the father he jokingly calls "General-Dad." He too breaks the rule about personalizing a subject -- in his case, a girl he impregnates and then has to trick into marriage. As each of his beliefs comes under assault, he begins to see his job as "just digging deeper and deeper into people until I find the worst in them." McClure doesn't become paunchy and seedy but his transformation into a sleek company-man version of Ballantine is just as dramatically distressing.

The men's personal relationships with wives and children further emphasize the characters as mirror images of soured idealism. Their reunion, though somewhat too melodramatic, ends with a bang -- literally.

St. Germain has directed his play with style, with a strong assist from Eric Renschler's clever set which is dominated by a trompe l'oeil wall of FBI file cabinets that reflect the duplicity of the activities being chronicled by regularly popping open to reveal tape recorders, phones, etc. It's too bad that this versatile backdrop could not have accommodated the desks which are now rolled on and off stage noisily and distractingly by prop handlers. The documentary flavor is bolstered by voiceovers that include Dick Cavett, host of the popular TV talk show on which guest John Lennon claimed the FBI was tapping his phone line in 1972. If you don't recognize some of the others, not to worry. The flavor that will linger is from St. Germain's story and the two fine actors bringing it to life.

Ears On A Beatle
Written and directed by Mark St. Germain
Cast: Dan Lauria, Bill Dawes. Voiceovers: Dick Cavett; Leon Wildes, Arlo Guthrie; Robert Vaughn; Geraldine Ferraro, Fred Savage
Sets: Eric Renschler
Costumes: Melissa Panzarello
Lighting Design: Jim Milkey
Sound Design: Randy Hansen
Running Time: 90 minutes
Stage II at the Consolati Performing Arts Center in Sheffield. (413/528-8888
July 2, 2003- July 19; opening July 6, 2003
Wednesday through Sunday at 7:30m p.m.
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer based on July 9th performance