The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings


SEARCH CurtainUp



NEWS (Etcetera)



Los Angeles






Free Updates
NYC Weather
A CurtainUp BerkshiresBerkshire Review
Cranwell Resort

There's a sucker born every minute. ---Phineas Taylor Barnum

The Porches Inn
 Gavin Waters as    Tom  Thumb
Two men on stilts (Marc Schaeffer and Jamie Price) shrink Gavin Waters' image to fit Tom Thumb .
Mark Bramble wasn't trying to make a sucker out of anyone when he sugar-coated legendary impresario P.T. Barnum's relationship with his wife Charity into a an endearing and enduring marital romance that invariably charmed the more earthbound "Chairy" into supporting the latest venture of her "Prince of Humbug." The circus showman who coined the phrase " the greatest show on earth " inspired Bramble's book for the 1980 musical bearing his name, but that show was intended as a big colorful circus show in the spirit of the great showman, never as a scholarly biography.

The musical's diddling with the facts of Barnum's career and his marriage (the marriage to Chairy was actually the first of three, none happy) in the interest of romance and spectacle resulted in a hit that ran 854 performances. It made Jim Dale a super star and o shone the spotlight on Glenn Close who created the role of Chairy.

Though Dale, who these days gives much pleasure to theater goers in straight acting roles (most recently Address Unknown and The Comedians ), left an indelible imprint on the title role, Barnum continues to be a crowd pleaser whenever it's staged. The revival currently at Chatham's own musical theater in the round is no exception. In fact, if you've never been to the Mac-Haydn you could be excused for thinking that the tiny circular stage was built especially for this bright and lively circus which has what seems like a small army of clowns, acrobats and young local gymnasts tumbling and stumbling all over the stage and aisles even before the show begins. While I've seen elegant classics like My Fair Lady on this same stage, this show seems especially made to order for this family friendly theater where it's common to see kids accompanied by parents as well as grandparents.

Brian Laycock doesn't walk a tightrope and isn't an especially high wattage Barnum, but his performance gains in strength as the show moves forward. Karla Shook's rich soprano and relaxed performance make for a warm and extremely likeable Chairy, whether she's singing the show's best ballad, "The Colors of My Life," with Laycock or the catchy "One Brick at a Time" with the chorus.

The major pleasure of this Barnum comes from the overall energy of the large cast as well as the clever scenic design and gorgeous costumes. Inventive touches abound -- a super-sized chair and sky high men on stilts to "downsize" the normal sized Gavin Waters' Tom Thumb and four gray, ceiling high fabric tubes put Dumbo the elephant on stage. Except for the "Black and White" number which features some terrific tap dancing the show's palette mixes American flag red, white and blue with a psychedelic rainbow.

The tiny playing area necessitates entrances and exits via three aisles and a good many blackouts, but director Jim Middleton keeps this big show moving along with amazing fluidity. Kelly L. Shook also deserves several rounds of applause for dealing with the challenge of choreographing for a large ensemble on the handkerchief-sized stage.

The Mac-Haydn Barnum may not feature big name actors or have a tightrope as did Broadway's St. James Theater or the Florida venue where Middleton himself recently played the lead, but no matter. Mr. Middleton and his gang of vibrant singers, clowns and acrobats have made this a spectacle that would have pleased even P.T. Barnum.

Unlike theaters elsewhere the Mac-Haydn doesn't try for edgy re-conceptions of popular musicals. Instead the theater sticks to its mission of reviving musicals true to the spirit of their creators. Barnum is the penultimate offering of an as usual full season, which will conclude with Rodgers' and Hammerstein's The King And I ( August 26 - September 5). If you're not from the neighborhood, plan to get to Chatham early enough to wander around this charming Columbia County town. Directions for getting there can be found at the Mac-Hadn web site,

Book by Mark Bramble
Music by Cy Coleman
Lyrics by Michael Stewart
Directed by: Jim Middleton
Cast: Chad Heuschober/Barker; Brian Laycock/Phineas Taylor Barnum; Karla Shook/Chairy Barnum, Kristen Clark/ Joice Heth; Gavin Waters/Tom Thumb; Chad Heuschobe/rJulius Goldschmidt; Katie Kuhlenschmidt/ Jenny Lind; Jamie Price/James A. Bailey; Michael Shiles/Ringmaster; Michael Hildebrandt/Chester Lyman; Richard Marson/Amos Scudder; Donald Panella/Sherwood Stratton & Humbert Morrisey; Sari Ganulin/Mrs. Sherwood Stratton; Lou Kerscher/Wilton; Marc Schaeffer/Edgar Templeton; Kelly L. Shook & Trisha Stever/1st and 2ndWoman; Josh Bishoff/Concert Master.
Clowns, Acrobats, Museum Patrons, Etc.: Carissa Bellando, Renee Brna, Corrie Beula, Kristen Clark, Sari Ganulin, Katie Kuhlenschmidt, Megan Orlowski, Kelly L. Shook, Trisha Stever, Karen Leggett, Josh Bishoff, Chad Heuschober, Michael Hildebrandt, Lou Kerscher, Richard Marson, Donald Panella, Jamie Price, Marc Schaeffer, Gavin Waters, Catina Laurendeau; Gymnasts from KJ's Gymastics: Juanita Eaton, Jennifer Stelling, Meredith Lukas,Brian Leggett, Angela Stelling, Lauren Sears
Set Design: Kristian Perry
Musical Director: Alexander Rovang
Lighting Design: Andrew Gmoser
Costume Design: Cathleen M. Crocker-Perry
Sound Design: Todd Hendricks
Choreographer: Kelly L. Shook
Drummer/Percussionist: Mary E. Rodriguez Mac-Haydn Theater, Rte. 203 in Chatham, NY.. 518-392-9292 website
August 12 - 22, 2004
Thurs. Fri., 2nd Wed. 8 p.m., Sat. 8:30 p.m., Sun 7 p.m. Mats: 1st Thurs. 2 p.m., Sat. 5 p.m., Sun. 2 p.m., 2nd Wed. 2 p.m.
Tickets: $21-$23. Reviewed by Elyse Sommer based on 8/18 matinee performance
Musical Numbers
Act One
  • There Is A Sucker Born Every Minute/Barnum
  • Thank God I'm Old/Joice Heth, Chorus
  • The Colors Of My Life/Chairy, Barnum
  • One Brick At A Time/Chairy, Chorus
  • Museum Song (Egress Song)/Barnum
  • I Like Your Style/Chairy & Barnum
  • Bigger Isn't Better/ Tom Thumb
  • Jenny Lind Obligato/Jenny Lind
  • Love Makes Such Fools Of Us All /Jenny Lind
  • Out There/Barnum
Act Two
  • Come Follow The Band/Barnum, Ringmaster, Chorus
  • Love Makes Such Fools of Us All (reprise)/Jenny Lind
  • Black And White/Ringmaster, Chairy, Barnum, Chorus
  • The Colors of my Life (Reprise)/Chairy, Barnum
  • Join The Circus/Barnum, Bailey, Chorus
  • Finale/Company
  • Finale Part II/Barnum
deb and harry's wonderful things -  crafts .  yarns

Historic Red Lion Inn

Berkshire Hikes Book Cover

Great Places to Eat, Shop, Stay

Sheffield Pottery
In Lee:
Pamela Loring Gifts
Morgan House Inn & Restaurant
In Lenox:
Andrew De Vries Sculptures

In Williamstown
Pappa Charlie's Deli
Thai Garden
Listing information:

m metaphors dictionary cover
6,500 Comparative Phrases including 800 Shakespearean Metaphors by CurtainUp's editor.
Click image to buy.
Go here for details and larger image.

Berkshire Main Page. . .  Berkshire Theater Index and Schedules. . .  Berkshire News Page. . .  Berkshire Review Archive. . .  A-Z Index All CurtainUp Reviews

©Copyright 2004, Elyse Sommer, CurtainUp.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from