The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings









etcetera- NEWS


See links at top of our Main Page







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review
Prodigal Son

Jesus Christ was no hero like I think of a hero. Heroes fight for life. Jesus just handed them his sword and said 'Kill me'.
—Jim adding Jesus to Socrates and Thomas More who he viewed as suicides rather than heroes during what is apparently a frequent chess game with Mr. Hoffman that's peppered with stimulating discourse that the teacher enjoys but cautions him not to let Headmaster Schmitt hear.
 Prodigal Son
Robert Sean Leonard and Timothee Chalamet (Photo Credit: Joan Marcus)
With Prodigal Son, John Patrick Shanley's trilogy based on his personal history has become a tetralogy. Like Defiance and Store Front Church it isn't quite on a par with the PulitzerPrizewinning Doubt. However, it is a compelling, well cast memory piece that benefits from MTC's as usual superb stagecraft, especially Santo Loquasto's evocative scenery and Paul Simon's incidental music.

Doubt and Defiance were about the hierarchal institutions Shanley knew as a Catholic high school student in the '60s and as a marine at Camp Lejeune in the '70s. Storefront Church was the result of his wandering through the Bronx many years later and then connecting the many little informal churches he saw to current financial and social problems. With Prodigal Son Mr. Shanley has returned to his teen years, this time taking us back to his junior and senior years at The Thomas More Preparatory School in New Hampshire. While packed with incident and passionate interchanges, the new play as directed by Shanley, plays out in just 90 well-paced minutes.

As the author's note in the program makes clear, this is Shanley's most autobiographical play. While changes were made to simplify and make a point here and there, even the names remain mostly unchanged in the interest of sharing these life-changing years of a troubled Bronx boy with the audience — a boy who as he puts it was "rather violent, a bit delusional, hungry for all kinds of things and wild-eyed as a rescue dog." Given the exclusive prep school setting what we have here is a '60s coming of age story seasoned with literary and philosophical dialogue.

Shanley did change the name of his alter ego to Jim Quinn. Theater veterans Robert Sean Leonard and Chris McGarry play Alan Hoffman the head of the English department and Carl Schmitt, headmaster and religion teacher who will determine whether the school will satisfy Jim's hunger for emotional connections and understanding of life's big questions. Unsurprisingly, the teachers have their own problems and the brilliant but troublesome outsider (the Bronx is an alien country to everyone at this small sequestered school) strongly affects both.

Theatergoers are likely to know Leonard and McGarry, the former a Tony Award winner making a welcome return to the stage after his long run in the House series. Both are excellent, but the role of Jim is the play's centerpiece and 21-year-old stage newcomer Timothee Chalamet whose work so far has been mostly on screen (notably as young Tom in Interstellar and Finn Walden in Homelandand the film) is very much their equal.

While not without humor, this is neither light entertainment or a romance. The only female character is headmaster Schmitt's wife Louise (Annika Boras making the most of a small but important role). She serves tea and sympathy, but no hanky panky, along with her private class for advanced English students. The tiny class in which Jim is enrolled is spending a semester exploring T. S. Eliot's "The Wasteland" which Jim doesn't understand or like. His dislike is based on his belief that it won't be good in a hundred years ("it isn't good now"); also his aversion to Eliot's appearance ("He looks like an undertaker"). What's more, Jim is more interested in Mrs. Schmitt's opinion of his own poem rather than Eliot's. She likes it but sees him using poetry as "a ladder to climb out of some terrible place."

Like Alan Hoffman she recognizes the boy's unusual mind. For that matter, so does Headmaster Schmitt but Jim's anti-social behavior (hitting younger boys, drinking, stealing, explosive remarks about religion) put him at odds with Hoffman and his wife's view of the boy as a star to be nurtured, rather than a disastrous presence best removed.
The subject of sex does come up in a scene with roommate Austin (an effective debut by David Potters), the only love affair for Jim is with books. And so, for anyone in the mood for Shanley in a more light weight, romantic mood a DVD of his hit movie Moonstruck is likely be preferable to this bookish, philosophical look at Jim's journey from the Bronx to bucolic New Hampshire.

Jim is 15 in the opening scene, 17 in the final one. Both these scenes have him address the audience directly with this sum-up of the up and down side of the experience: "I always had a book. I was fifteen. Do you remember fifteen? For me, it was a special, beautiful room in hell." The books he's never without include writers like Socrates and Dickens, but he also finds more wisdom worth listening to in historical romance writer Rafael Sabatini than most teachers he's encountered — that's all except Mr. Hoffman with whom he develops a close relationship that includes chess games peppered with some of the play's best dialogue.

Like many small New England schools, Thomas More is housed in a former private mansion set amidst tall, stately trees. A far cry from the streets of the Bronx. A replica of that mansion looms in the distance as Jim introduces himself before a diner rolls out for the interview with the headmaster which will determine his future. This is the first of numerous locations thus rolled on and off stage on a wooden platform to accommodate interactions in Schmitt's office and home, Jim and Austin's room, Hoffman's living room, a school classroom and the grounds outside the school.

The plot's increasing tensions are propelled forward by the question as to whether the desperate neediness that drives Jim's self-destructive actions will prevent the school from helping him find his way out of his go-nowhere inner city background and into the less lonely, more meaningful life he yearns for. Instead of exciting swordplay, as in Jim's beloved Sabatino novels, to bring all these tensions to a head, the climax in Prodigal Son is fought with verbal confrontations, the most poignant and disturbing between Jim and Alan Hoffman, the always supportive English teacher.

In view of the admittedly autobiographical plot foundation, I suppose you wouldn't be wrong to say that Prodigal Son has a happy ending since Shanley-cum-Jim's two years at Thomas More were followed by a successful life as a stage and screen writer. But then there's that opening and closing description of his time there as "a special, beautiful room in hell" to make you ponder the bittersweet undercurrents of this poignant stage memoir.

Prodigal Son, written & directed by John Patrick Shanley
Cast:Annika Boras (Louise Schmitt), Timothee Chalamet (Jim Quinn), Robert Sean Leonard (Alan Hoffman), Chris McGarry (Carl Schmitt), David Potters (Austin).
Scenic Design:Santo Loquasto
Costume Design:Jennifer Von Mayrhauser
Lighting Design: Natasha Katz
Sound Design:Fitz Patton
Original Music:Paul Simon
Dialect Coach: Charlotte Fleck
Stage Manager; Kyle Gates
From 1/19/16; opening 2/09/16; closing 3/27/16
Running Time: 90 minutes, no intermission.
MTC at City Center Stage 1
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer at February 6th press preview
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Prodigal Son
  • I disagree with the review of Prodigal Son
  • The review made me eager to see Prodigal Son
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted add to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter
Subscribe to our FREE email updates: E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message. If you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
Slings & Arrows  cover of  new Blu-Ray cover
Slings & Arrows- view 1st episode free

Book Of Mormon MP4 Book of Mormon -CD
Our review of the show

©Copyright 2016, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from