The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings






Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants









Free Updates
Writing for Us
A CurtainUp Review
Meet Me In St. Louis

Someday soon we all will be together
If the fates allow.
Until then, we'll have to muddle through somehow So have yourself a merry little Christmas now.
— From "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas"

Gabrielle Piacentile and Bonnie Frase
Gabrielle Piacentile and Bonnie Fraser in Meet Me in St. Louis
(Photo: Carol Rosegg)
I suspect that many people first encountered Meet Me In St. Louis as I did. A relative (in my case my grandfather) sat us down in front of a television screen around the holiday season and told us about a wonderful holiday movie they had seen when they were younger — and on came the compelling 1944 classic about a well-to-do family in St. Louis about to be moved to New York City right on the eve of the Louisiana Purchase Exposition in 1904.

An odd but extremely effective mixture of music and melancholy, Meet Me In St. Louis (itself based upon Sally Benson's novel The Kensington Stories) was one of the few works to reverse the typical trend of Broadway musical to big screen— in fact, it was over forty years before the first Broadway adaptation appeared at the Gershwin Theater, starring Donna Kane as Esther Smith (played memorably by Judy Garland in the movie) and Charlotte Moore as Mrs. Smith. Now Moore has brought the story back to life at the Irish Repertory Theatre (where she is artistic director) and I'm happy to report that there is still as much spirit as ever in the telling.

It shouldn't come as a surprise that the well-respected Irish Rep knows how to stage a production, but Meet Me In St. Louis is in some ways a tricky show to pull off. Besides the inevitable comparisons between stage and screen (and the performers in each), the musical contains surprisingly complex dance numbers and some interesting staging challenges, all of which are overcome through Moore's careful direction and Barry McNabb's choreography (even more impressive given the limited room for performance). The set and lighting design, by Tony Straiges and Brian Nason respectively, are similarly well done. The set feels very much like a turn of the century dollhouse. The clever use of lighting fixtures brings the audience from trolley to fairground without stretching the bounds of credulity too far. And the costumes, designed by Tracy Christensen, are particularly fine, especially Esther's stunning red Christmas ball dress, which doesn't in the least suffer in comparison with Garland's outfit in the movie scene—nor does the music which is directed with tact and skill by John Bell.

Most critical to the success of any musical are its performers, and here as well this production rarely misses a beat. George Irving is probably the best known actor in the group, and his rendition of the good-humored Grandpa Prophater is spot on throughout. Almost all of the cast delivers similarly good performances, from Becky Barta's confident version of the maid Katie to Sarah Pfisterer's gentle Mrs. Smith (played by Moore in the original Broadway production) to Gabrielle Piacentile's feisty Tootie.

Esther, the heart of the show, is played exceedingly well by Bonnie Fraser, who has to somehow mix spirit, grace and forcefulness with wistful longing without seeming maudlin or trite. And so she does. Her beautiful rendering of "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas" is one of the show's highlights.

The limitations of the production probably have less to do with performance and more with the format itself. There simply isn't quite enough time to give the story space to breathe and develop, and so, while the movie had a darkness to it which elevated it above the usual vacuous holiday fare, the storyline here is so accelerated as to undercut the narrative subtlety (the announcement of the family's imminent move doesn't even happen until a third of the way into the second act). The result is a rather lighter version than what might have been intended originally — a minor objection given Moore's careful and balanced direction which combined with mostly good performances creates a worthy revival that should have theatergoers singing (or at least humming!) its praises for a long time.

Songs by Hugh Martin and Ralph Blane
Based on The Kensington Stories by Sally Benson and the MGM motion picture Meet Me in St. Louis
Directed by Charlotte Moore
Musical Direction by John Bell
Choreography by Barry McNabb

Cast: Becky Barta (Katie), Doug Boes (Warren Sheffield), Merideth Kaye Clark (Rose Smith), Kerry Conte (Lucille Ballard), Colin Donnell (John Truitt), Bonnie Fraser (Esther Smith), John Hickok (Mr. Alonzo Smith), George S. Irving (Grandpa Prophater), Sarah Pfisterer (Mrs. Anna Smith), Danielle Piacentile (Agnes), Gabrielle Piacentile (Tootie), Ashley Robinson (Lon Smith)
Set Design: Tony Straiges
Costume Design: Tracy Christensen
Lighting Design: Brian Nason
Sound Design: Murmod, Inc.
Hair & Wig Design: Robert-Charles Vallance
Orchestra: Piano, John Bell; Cello, Melanie Mason; Violin, Diane Montalbine
Running time: 2 hours including fifteen minute intermission
The Irish Repertory Theatre, 132 West 22nd St., 212-727-2737
Web Site:
From 12/06/06-1/28/07-extended to 2/18/07; opening 12/14/06
Wed.-Sat. @ 8 p.m., Wed., Sat.-Sun. @ 3 p.m.
Tickets: Regular $60, Matinee $55
Reviewed by Gregory Wilson based on December 13th preview performance

Musical Numbers
Act One
· Meet Me in St. Louis / Tootie, Postman, Agnes, Grandpa, Lon, Rose, Esther, Mr. Smith, Katie
· The Boy Next Door / Esther
· Meet Me in St. Louis / Grandpa, Agnes, Esther, Rose, Tootie, Mrs. Smith
· Whenever I'm With You / Lon, Rose, Esther, Grandpa, Agnes, Tootie
· You'll Hear a Bell / Mrs. Smith
· A Raving Beauty / Warren, Rose
· Skip to My Lou / Lon, Rose, Ensemble
· Drunk Song / Tootie
· Under the Bamboo Tree / Esther, Tootie, Agnes
· Over the Banister / John, Esther
· Trolley Song / Esther, Ensemble

Act Two
· A Touch of the Irish / Katie, Esther, Rose, Agnes, Tootie
· The Boy Next Door (reprise) / John, Esther
· A Day in New York / Mr. Smith, Mrs. Smith, Grandpa, Esther, Rose
· You'll Hear A Bell (reprise) / Mrs. Smith
· Wasn't It Fun / Mr. Smith, Mrs. Smith
· The Banjo / Lon, Ensemble
· You Are For Loving / John, Esther
· Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas / Esther
· Meet Me in St. Louis (reprise) / Ensemble
broadway musicals: the 101 greatest shows of all time
Easy-on-the budget super gift for yourself and your musical loving friends. Tons of gorgeous pictures.

Leonard Maltin's Classic Movie Guide
Leonard Maltin's 2007 Movie Guide

At This Theater Cover
At This Theater

Leonard Maltin's 2005 Movie Guide

The Broadway Theatre Archive>


©Copyright 2006, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from