ADVERTISING AT CURTAINUP
Short Term Listings
BOOKS and CDs
LETTERS TO EDITOR
A CurtainUp Review
Abraham Lincoln’s Big Gay Dance Party
The production starts with a charming prologue of sorts: a couple short scenes from a fourth grade Christmas pageant, our Founding Fathers having Christmas. It takes place in a small town in Illinois, which happens to be Abraham Lincoln’s birthplace. All goes amuck when the Lincoln character begins to talk about his bedfellow Joshua Speed, and his love for this man. With a song-and-dance segue, the premise of the next two and a half hours is introduced. The fourth grade teacher, Harmony Green (Pippa Pearthree) has been fired and put on trial by the town for stating Lincoln’s sexual preference as homo. We are to watch the story of the trial from three different perspectives – the prosecutor (Robert Hogan), the defense attorney (Stephanie Pope Caffey), and an NYC journalist writing about the trail (Arnie Burton). To add a democratic flair, an audience member is picked randomly, and they chose which order these stories are told.
Seems a disjointed premise for a show with this title? It is. Sure, there are dance-party breakout moments, and the oft off-color humor. But ultimately, the play is barely about Honest Abe, or even dance parties, but about contemporary prejudices and the malice that can get in the way of good intentions. Yes, there are some provocative concepts truly at play in this setup. It is a shame the show’s title misrepresents, but it is more of a shame that ALBGD has a half-baked plot that is filled with unexplained jumps, and a completely unfinished ending.
The cast, who all play multiple roles, try heartily to make the evening dynamic. Everyone plays Abraham Lincoln at one point or another (and often all at once), along with taking on two to four other roles in the various narratives. The characterizations are good, and only come across as stereotypical when they’re playing the kids who were in the pageant. But their efforts are mired by Chris Smith’s slow direction and awkward staging.
ALBGDP did provide me with an enjoyable evening, and I could see why this strange little concept fared well at the fringe festival, among its rough-and-tumble colleagues. But it felt as though the show’s off-broadway debut didn’t include desperately needed revisions or re-examining of the story – what, exactly is this trial about anyway?
On the bright side, what a fun party fact this show provides me – Abraham Lincoln may in fact have been gay! And I saw a play about it! Alas, though, the title of the production does make people skeptical about the legitimacy of my claims.