The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings

A CurtainUp Review
School of Rock

Don't Just Sit And Take It,
Stick It To The Man!

— Lyric from the song empowering the kids to march to their own drummer

school of rock
Alex Brightman and cast members (Photo: Matthew Murphy
Broadway musicals come and some go on and on for years. For Andrew Lloyd Webber's Phantom of the Opera it's been an amazing thirty-nine years. His poetry inspired Cats purred at the Winter Garden for eighteen years. And now Webber has reclaimed that theater for a stage adaptation of the hit 2003 film School of Rock.

It may not be big on originality, depth or high art, but like Wicked School of Rock is a four-ticket seller. And, judging by the audience at the last matinee before the official opening, it will have plenty of adults tapping into their inner rocker along with kids of all ages.

Not being a rockaholic myself, I would have liked the decibel level lowered — at least low enough to hear all the lyrics and to have me less worried about what being repeatedly right on stage will do to the eardrums of the super talented young ensemble. That said, those kids are irresistible; and so is Alex Brightman's animated, non-stop physical performance as their politically incorrect, substitute teacher. If the show follows the film's success, Brightman is likely to lose some of that out of shape chubbiness that's part of his character's persona, as it was for Jack Black in the film

I didn't see the original film but did read some recaps and reviews of it. Though the book is now by Julian Fellowes (yes, the same Fellowes who was responsible for the elegant period tv-soap opera Downton Abbey ), the staged School of Rock seems to remain true to that film's plot and humor, though probably sanitized for family audiences by Fellowes. Since, it's all pretty predictable even for anyone unfamiliar with the movie, I plead not guilty of being a spoilsport with this summary: Though his friend Ned (Spencer Morris) has abandoned his rock star dreams to become a licensed substitute teacher, Dewey Finn (Brightman) still nurtures that dream. But things aren't going well for him. He's been fired from his band and his record shop job, and Ned's girl friend Patty (Mamie Parris) wants him to pay rent or get out of their apartment. So, when Dewey answers a call for Ned to take on a high-paying gig at a private prep school, he impetuously pretends to be Ned. He's obviously highly unsuited for the job, especially given the school's rigid conformity. Yet, he soon enlists his fifth-grade clas to share his rock enthusiasm, form a band and ultimately win over uptight principal Rosalie Mullins (Boggess) and even the parents.

All these unbelievable but entertaining antics, are smoothly directed by Laurence Connor to lead to the kids exuberantly competing at the Battle of the Bands contest. It's a concert style finale, which means ultra loud and blindingly bright flashes of light

For all its adherence to the film, School of Rock combines new music by Mr. Webber and the unfortunately often drowned out lyrics by Glenn Slater with three of the film's songs ("The End of Time", "Math Is a Wonderful Thing" and the title song). Webber isn't nearly as out of his league as Dewey is at that elite school — remember Jesus Christ Superstar? The show's big breakout number, "Stick it to the Man," proves that he hasn't forgotten how to write catchy rock tunes. His "You're In the Band Now" cleverly includes quotes from a string of famous musicians (see the song list below). And with "Where Did the Rock Go?" he has, as usual, written a melodic ballad for leading lady Sierra Boggess. She also has a wonderful moment singing Mozart's "Queen of the Night" in a scene (mos like a Fellowes touch) in which she's leading the kids in a classical music lesson.

There are also plenty of bouncy numbers for the kids, most of whom are in their early teens and some even pre-teen. While Brightman's Dewey is the show's star, the youngsters are very much his co-stars and the emotional connection between this unlikely teacher and his students is nicely conveyed as Dewey helps all to gain confidence to show off their untapped instrument, singing and acting talents. He makes guitar prodigy Brandon Niederauer's Zack the band's lead guitarist, and lets Luca Padovan use his taste for female fashions as the group's "stylist." Even Summer (Isabella Russo), the class smarty pants , is roped in as the band's manager. Of course there's also the shyest student, Tonika (Robbie MacKenzie), to suddenly find her voice with a ,brief and lovely rendition of John Newton's "Amazing Grace. In his own frenzied way this rock obsessed slacker clearly isn't such a bad teacher. No wonder that when he's finally discovered and feeling down and out, the students bring him back with the winning "If Only You Would Listen."

The choreography by Joann M. Hunter consists mostly of hyper-active bobbing up and down. But with those youngsters doing the rocking it's great fun. Set and costume designer Anna Louizos deserves a shout out for the sliding walls she's created to take us to a variety of locations.

Forget about looking for any especially deep or controversial themes. Dewey's urging the kids to "stick it to the man" does touch on the redemptive and self-actualizing power of music even may strike some as putting down serious learning. But this really isn't a message musical. The overall improbability of everything keeps School of Rock strictly what it is — a not to be taken seriously hard rocking, feel good romp.

Musical Numbers
All music by Andrew Lloyd Webber & Lyrics by Glenn Slater, except per numbers with asterisks before titles: * Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. . .**music & lyrics by Jack Black and Warren Fitzgerald. . .***music & lyrics by John Newton. . . ****music & lyrics by Jack Black and Mike White. . . *****music & lyrics by Mike White and Sammy James, Jr.
Act One
  • I'm Too Hot for You/ No Vacancy and Dewey
  • When I Climb to the Top of Mount Rock / Dewey
  • Horace Green Alma Mater /Rosalie, Students and Teachers
  • Here at Horace Green/ Rosalie
  • Variatons7/Dewey and Ned
  • Children of Rock /Dewey and Ned
  • Mount Rock (Reprise) /Patty
  • *Queen of the Night/Rosalie, Dewey, Gabe
  • You're in the Band (with quotes from Mick Jagger, Keith Richards, Ritchie Blackmore, Ian Gillan, Roger Glover, Jon Lord, Ian Anderson Price, Lou Reed, Ludwig Von Beethovem/ Dewey and Students
  • You're in the Band (Reprise) / Dewey and Students
  • If Only You Would Listen / Students
  • **In the End of Time)/ Dewey
  • Faculty Quadrille /Teachers
  • In the End of Time (Band Practice) / Dewey and Students
  • Stick It to the Man /Dewey and Students
  • In the End of Time (The Audition)/ Dewey and Students<
  • Stick It to the Man (Reprise) /Dewey and Students
Act Two
  • Time to Play/ Summer and Students
  • ***Amazing Grace/ Tomika
  • ****Math Is a Wonderful Thing/ Dewey and Students
  • Where Did the Rock Go? / Rosalie
  • *****School of Rock (Band Practice) /Dewey and Students
  • Dewey's Confession / Dewey, Rosalie, Patty, Ned and Parents
  • If Only You Would Listen (Reprise) / Students
  • I'm Too Hot for You (Reprise)/ No Vacancy
  • School of Rock (Reprise)// Dewey and Students
  • Stick It to the Man (Reprise) / Dewey and Students

Search CurtainUp in the box below Back to Curtainup Main Page

School of Rockā€”The Musical
Book by Julian Fellowes based 2003 film of the same title
. Music from the movie, with new music by Andrew Lloyd Webber and lyrics by Glenn Slater
Directed by Laurence Connor
Cast: Sierra Boggess (Rosalie), Alex Brightman (Dewey), Spencer Moses (Ned), Mamie Parris (Patty), Taylor Caldwell (Shonelle), Evie Dolan (Katie), Carly Gendell (Marcy), Shahadi Wright Joseph (Madison), Ethan Khusidman (Mason), Bobbi MacKenzie (Tomika),Dante Melucci (Freddy), Brandon Niederauer (Zack), Luca Padovan (Billy),Jared Parker (Lawrence), Isabella Russo (Summer), Jersey Sullivan (James),Corinne Wilson (Sophie)
Ensemble: Emily Cramer,Natalie Charle Ellis, Alan H. Green, Michael Hartney, John Hemphill, Merritt David Janes, Jaygee Macapugay,Cassie Okenka, Tally Sessions,Jonathan Wagner, Jeremy Woodard.
Choreography by JoAnn M. Hunter
Scenic and Costume Design by Anna Louizos
Lighting Design by Natasha Katz
Sound Design by Mick Potter
Hair Design: Josh Marquette
Music Director: Darren Ledbetter
Stage Manager: Bonnie L. Baker
Time:2 hours and 20 minutes with one 15-minute intermission.
Winter Garden Theater 634 Broadway, at 50th Street
From 11/02/15; opening 12/06/closing 1/20/19
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer at 12/05 press matinee

Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of School of Rock
  • I disagree with the review of School of Rock
  • The review made me eager to see School of Rock
Click on the address link E-mail: esommer@curtainup.com
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted at http://curtainupnewlinks.blogspot.com to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter
Subscribe to our FREE email updates: E-mail: esommer@curtainup.com
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message. If you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.

©Copyright 2016, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from esommer@curtainup.com