A CurtainUp Review
This is my second visit to Old Hats. And, honestly, I was wondering as I settled into my seat at the Irene Diamond theater, if Irwin and Shiner might have lost some of the magic of their show's 2013 iteration. Well, despite the fact that Irwin has gained a few more laugh lines around his expressive eyes and Shiner's hair has thinned a tad, they definitely deliver the goods in this fresh version of their slapstick show.
As again helmed by Tina Landau Old Hats is unlike anything else being staged in New York. If you missed it in its first go-round, catch this first-rate revival. It's a terrific investment of two hours of your life.
Review of Old Hats during its 2013 runBill Irwin and David Shiner, that clownish duo who starred in the Tony Award-winning show Fool Moon, return to the New York boards for more slapstick, gags, and laughs in Old Hats. Co-created and performed by Irwin and Shiner, and directed by Tina Landau, this production at the Pershing Square Signature Center partly draws on their old stage material but gives it a fresh polish and spin. Joined on stage by Nellie McKay and The Band, Irwin and Shiner remind us here that clowning is no theatrical step-child but a full-fledged member of the arts.
Outfitted in top hats, tails, baggy pants and horn-rims, Irwin and Shiner are an ideal team on stage. Often described as New Vaudevillians or New Wave clowns, these funnymen continue to evolve and redefine Clown art.
In the opening number, the duo play a game of theatrical one-upmanship, each trying to claim the spotlight, and alternately winning and losing at their narcissistic game. Whether its tossing their hats high into the air, and catching them by their brims, or upstaging one another with flashy moves, we see grandstanding in a very comic vein. This competition for being Number One will become a strong motif during the evening, and not-so-subtly play out in each comic skit.
Old Hats is not only loaded with laughs, but Irwin and Shiner suggest that the show is digitally loading itself before our eyes with comic material. Indeed we literally see that "loading" computer screen image at the onset of Act 1, projected onto a huge multi-media screen, which serves as a backdrop for many of the evening's vignettes. While retaining some tried-and-true routines (Irwin signature gag of being sucked foot-first into the wings by a mysterious force is tucked into the show), Old Hats adds new-fangled material. Perhaps the most New Age skit is "The Businessman," in which Irwin postures as a frenetic businessman in the Big City, clutching an iPad as if it was an extension of his own arm. We watch as Irwin's character uses his high-tech toy for wheeling-and-dealing and connecting himself to the Digital World. What makes this skit not only pertinent but deeply psychological is that his consumer is earnestly-and surreally--struggling to master his high-tech gadget without being consumed by it. It begs the question: When it comes to human beings and the new technology in a dog-eat-dog world, how does one prevent the tail from wagging the dog?
The light-hearted show has its sobering, and even tragic-tinged, moments. This is most conspicuous in "The Hobo," where Shiner plays a tramp figure who would be quite at home in a Beckett play. With whiskey bottle in hand, Shiner's tramp trudges on stage and decides to sit down on a park bench right next to a trash can. Out of hunger, or perhaps idle curiosity, the man rummages through the trash can in search of things that might serve his present needs. We then watch as Shiner's hobo slowly pulls out, in various states of disrepair, a red rose, a stuffed teddy bear, a "real" dead cat, a (headless) Jack-in-the-box toy, and ultimately a satiny sheet that he ingeniously shapes into a surrogate lover. Of all the evening's vignettes, this one is the most poignant.
To add more comic energy to the proceedings Nellie McKay acts as an eccentric musical director and multi-talented performer on the piano, the ukulele, and cello. The blonde-haired McKay is cute as a Barbie doll but immediately establishes that she is somebody to be reckoned with, and more than just eye-candy. Whether she's crooning a song at the piano at the edge of the stage or joining Irwin and Shiner in one of their routines, she always asserts her savoir faire. Or as she puts it in her opening number, "Won't U Please B Nice:" "Oh don't you love this romancing/ Know that it's your life you're chancing. . ." McKay is nobody's fool here, and not only sings cannily about romantic love and feminism, but keeps the evening from slipping into that Old Boys school mind-set.
Beyond McKay and a spunky Band that spins out upbeat numbers, other supporting performers are recruited from the audience by Shiner. Once he pulls his "victims" on stage, he does a spoof of an old Western flick with his fledgling artists, overseeing them as they rehearsed their parts. It's hilarious to follow this melodrama-in-progress about an unfaithful mole and her vengeful boyfriend. Shiner bosses everybody on the film set, undermining all of their acting and directing attempts with his mocking gestures and facial expressions. After several rehearsals, however, he finally gave his nod to these would-be artists and handed a faux Oscar statuette to the film's make-shift director.
Having had the great good luck of seeing Bill Irwin in his Helen Hayes Award-winning performance at the Arena Stage in Washington, D.C. in 1985, and both Irwin and Shiner in Fool Moon on Broadway, I could appreciate this production as both a retrospective and au courant theatre event. It takes the best of their old material and builds upon it. There's nothing stale here. Even the stage spaghetti that is used creatively in one culinary scene has a fresh al dente twist here.
This clown show raises the bar on clowning, with its acrobatic finesse and intellectual bite. Irwin and Shiner put a spade to their clowning roots here and grow a brilliant new piece that has one foot in the past, one in the present, and surely plants them in the genealogical line of great clowns like Harpo Marx, Buster Keaton, and Charlie Chaplin.
The earlier production began 2/12/13 and it's original 4/14/13 closing was extended to 5/09/13.