The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings

A CurtainUp Review
Joan of Arc: Into the Fire
"Take my dress and take my hair,
Sword and fire, be my prayer!"

Joan of Arc: Into the Fire
The company of Joan of Arc: Into the Fire, with Jo Lampert at center (Photo: Joan Marcus)
Joan of Arc is introduced to children as a heroine: a pioneering woman who proudly stood in the name of justice for her country and met an untimely end at the hands of men unable to tolerate her views. But Joan's story is hardly a tidy one. She was driven towards violent uprising by a voice of God that only she could hear. Even as she made every effort to shun womanhood, her authority depended as much on the power of her words as on anatomical features proving her virginity.

"David Byrne's new rock musical Joan of Arc: Into the Fire aspires to be an explosive retelling of Joan's story that doesn't shy away from gruesome details or the complications of the protagonist's motivations and legacy. In many ways, the project recalls Byrne's earlier pop opera Here Lies Love, in which he explored the life of former Philippines first lady Imelda Marcos in an immersive discotheque setting.

While Into the Fire lacks a participatory element, the biographical project is at its core the same: the use of a specific genre of music as a means of giving a new voice and quality to the central figure's story and character. Alex Timbers once again directs, and much of Here Lies Love's acclaimed design team return as well.

Into the Fire is ambitious, skillfully sung, and often quite visually impressive, but it falters on a narrative level. While the show gestures towards the complexities behind the character of Joan (played with impressive fire and venom by Jo Lampert), it skirts around much of her back story and glosses over significant moments.

This is a pervasive issue related, in part, to the fast pace of the ninety-minute show. A few minutes in, Joan first hears the word of heaven (made unnecessarily explicit by a spotlight with a shade opening and closing —an effect vaguely recalling the trumpet-voiced adults in the Peanuts TV specials). At what may be the most crucial single moment in her character's life, Lampert hardly has time to register, struggle with, question, or delight in the weight of Joan's revelation before launching into an anthem confidently declaring herself a prophet.

Similarly, a test set up for Joan in the court of the Dauphin (Kyle Selig)— France's as-yet uncrowned king— is introduced as if it will have real heft and consequences. But these are hardly explored when the challenge is solved in seconds, to little response. Such moments take place throughout the show, and it leaves the characters feeling shallow, as if they're simply avatars for historical reenactment.

Byrne is (needless to say) a talented musician and orchestrator, and his songs for the show make powerful use of the large ensemble cast. Over the course of the musical, though, we start to recognize echoes of the same several core arrangements reappearing time and time again. The idea of assigning each character their own musical "signature" is a compelling one—especially in a show with a multitude of smaller roles—but the execution is perhaps too reserved. The result can come off as repetitive, and threaten to cross into monotony.

The staging similarly struggles to stay dynamic, given the amount of time spent with a crowd gathered around Joan as she stands center stage. The choreography by Stephen Hoggett and production design do help counter this The choreography by Stephen Hoggett and production design do help counter this, however.

Depictions of battle in the show tend to be in the vein of the iconic Les Mis image of the flock around a waving flag, but when it comes to the actual fighting, Hoggett ingeniously uses movement to abstract and allude to battle without using traditional stage combat. Similarly, his twisting, contorting choreography deepens the impact of Joan's misfortunes after being captured by the British.

Clint Ramos provides a thoughtful costume design honoring both the historical context and the rock vibe of the show. A sparse set by Christopher Barreca nicely complements the special effects design by Jeremy Chernick and the projection design by Darrel Maloney, the latter of which offers useful background information throughout the show. Lighting design by Justin Townsend further builds a sense of place and heightens the mood of the music, though the blinding reflection of the spotlight in Joan's armor occasionally proves a distracting nuisance.

Of crucial importance to this loud rock musical is Cody Spencer's successfully imperceptible sound design. Actors, instruments and effects are harmoniously balanced and come through crystal clear.

And while the Public (reasonably) warns perspective attendees of the "rock concert level noise," the levels are humane — no need to worry about your ears ringing the rest of the night.

Despite some strong pieces, the whole of Joan of Arc: Into the Fire never ignites the way it aims to do. Because the narrative arc of the show is so rushed, much of what should be an emotionally stirring show comes off feeling distant and even clinical at times. It's clear that Byrne's concert musical sincerely wants to be a character study. Instead, it feels more like an encyclopedia entry.

Musical Numbers
  • What Can One Person Do? (Joan and Ensemble)
  • Somehow a Brightness (Joan and Ensemble)
  • A Prayer for Everyone (Baudricourt, Joan, and Ensemble)
  • Sword and Fire (Joan and Ensemble)
  • I Believe/A Crown for the King (Baudricourt, Joan, La Tremouille, Examiner, Dauphin, and Ensemble)
  • A Soldier Like Me (Baudricourt, Joan, and Ensemble)
  • Battle Prayer (Joan)
  • My Banner (Joan, Baudricourt, and Ensemble)
  • Holy Ghost (Joan, Ensemble of her troops, and some English soldiers)
  • We Need to Help the Human Being (Cauchon, Warwick, and Ensemble)
  • A Glorious Day (Fear Not) (Baudricourt, Joan, and Ensemble)
  • It's All Up to Me (Joan, King Charles, La Tremouille, Baudricourt, and Ensemble)
  • Have Faith, Be Strong/This Beautiful Compromise (Joan, La Tremouille, King Charles, Baudricourt, and Ensemble of soldiers and townspeople)
  • Satan's Spawn (Warwick, Cauchon, Examiner, and Ensemble)
  • The Reason I Must Fight (Joan, Cauchon, and Ensemble of priests and judges)
  • Dear God (Joan)
  • My Life and This Girl (Cauchon and Ensemble)
  • State of Grace (Joan, Cauchon, Baudricourt, and Ensemble of priests and judges)
  • Body Parts (Joan, Cauchon, and Ensemble of priests and judges)
  • God's Messenger (Reprise) (Joan and Ensemble)
  • Kindness and Comfort/Save Your Soul (Joan, Cauchon, and Ensemble of priests and judges)
  • Water of Affliction (Joan, Cauchon, and Warwick)
  • God's Army (Joan, Cauchon, Warwick, and Ensemble of priests)
  • Oh Merciful Lord (Warwick and English soldier)
  • Send Her to Heaven (Isabelle)

Search CurtainUp in the box below Back to Curtainup Main Page

Joan of Arc: Into the Fire
Book, Music, and Lyrics by David Byrne
Choreography by Steven Hoggett
Directed by Alex Timbers
with Terence Archie (Warwick); James Brown III (Priest, Judge); Jonathan Burke (Priest, Judge); Rodrick Covington (Priest, Judge); Sean Allan Krill (Bishop Cauchon); Jo Lampert (Joan); Mike McGowan (La Tremouille); Dimitri Joseph Moïse (Swing); Mary Kate Morrissey (Standby for Joan and Isabelle); Adam Perry (Priest, Judge); John Schiappa (Priest, Judge); Kyle Selig (Dauphin, King Charles); Michael James Shaw (Baudricourt); and Mare Winningham (Isabelle)
Scenic Design: Christopher Barreca
Costume Design: Clint Ramos
Lighting Design: Justin Townsend
Sound Design: Cody Spencer
Projection Design: Darrel Maloney
Special Effects Design: Jeremy Chernick
Wigs, Hair, and Make-up Design: Dave Bova and J. Jared Janas
Orchestrations and Arrangements: David Byrne
Additional Orchestrations and Arrangements: Kris Kukul
Artistic Associates: Catie Davis and Katie Spelman
Music Coordinator: Michael Aarons
Music Director: Kris Kukul
Production Stage Manager: Scott Rowen
Running Time: 1 hours and 30 minutes with no intermission
The Public Theater, Newman Theater, 425 Lafayette Street (at Astor Place)
Tickets: $120; (212) 967-7555,, or in person at the theater
From 2/14/2017; opened 3/15/2017; closing 4/30/2017
Performance times: Tuesdays–Fridays at 8:30 pm; Saturdays and Sundays at 2:30 pm and 8:30 pm (no 8:30 performance on Sunday, April 9); and an additional performance Wednesday, April 5, at 1:30 pm
Reviewed by Jacob Horn based on 3/10/2017 performance

Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Joan of Arc: Into the Fire
  • I disagree with the review of Joan of Arc: Into the Fire
  • The review made me eager to see Joan of Arc: Into the Fire
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted at to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter

©Copyright 2017, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from