The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings
A CurtainUp Review

Don't cry for me, Argentina
The truth is I never left you

— from Evita's most famous song.
Michael Cerveris and Elena Roger
(Photo credit: Richard Termine)
To paraphrase from Evita's signature aria:
Don't cry for stars and stagings of Evitas from years past
The truth is this revival is powerfully staged and cast.

Baron Lloyd-Webber has certainly lorded it over his colleagues in the musical theater world when it comes to hit making. The chandelier dropping Phantom of the Opera still has ticket holders snaking around the block after more than twenty years. Now two of his collaborations with lyricist Tim Rice, Jesus Christ Superstar and Evita are back on Broadway. While I'm not a fan of the former, I love the lushness of the Evita score. And even though the story is hardly a 100% accurate or fully detailed there's something about the soap-operatic grandeur of the story that's as irresistible as a good beach read or a mini series like Downton Abbey.

The new Evita — and all of you who are old enough to have seen Harold Prince's 1979 production, even those who like my friend whose job at an international corporation involved taking visiting clients to Evita about a dozen times, this is very much a new and quite wonderful Evita. British director Michael Grandage has fully exploited this sung-through musical's operatic grandeur. No minimal set for him but a lavishly designed and lit affair that would be right at home in an opera house. Somehow Christopher Oram's grand design fills in the sketchy bio-drama with shadings that make for a fuller picture of the power hungry, dictatorial undercurrents in this story of a less than pure Cinderella and the equally flawed Prince at whose side she will become a national icon.

Enriching Oram's stunning stage pictures and true to the period costumes is Neil Austin's spectacular, mood and narrative enhancing lighting. This is evident the minute the curtain emblazoned with giant images of the production's power couple, Eva and Juan Peron (Michael Cerveris) rises. on the opening scene, the funeral for Eva who has just succumbed to cancer at thirty-three. At the top half of the stage we see projectionist Zachary Borovay's video footage of the actual funeral procession. Below the Ensemble sings "Requiem" bathed in a grissaile pallette that makes the filmed and live people look all of a piece. Stagecraft doesn't get much better than this

The tunes that have embedded themselves in the ears even of those who know them only through the film starring Madonna or on cast album and other CD's are still there. It's a melody rich as ever score, that makes it easy to forgive some of Tim Rice's more awkward lyrics. What's more this isn't just another one big, much reprised show stopper score. Besides, the most famous aria, "Don't Cry For Me Argentina," there are challenging solo and ensemble turns like "On the Night of a Thousand Stars," "Buenos Aires," "The Art of the Possible," and " Another Suitcase in Another Hall."To add to what's new this time around, Lloyd Webber and David Cullen have updated Latin-flavored orchestrations of which Rob Ashford takes full advantaged with sizzling choreography that includes pas de deux and ensemble tangos, exotic waltzes foot-stomping generals.

The heavy infusion of the Latin flavored dancing is especially apt since this production's Eva Peron is an Argentinian and a seasoned dancer. To get the inevitable comparisons to the original Broadway Eva out of the way. It was Patti LuPone, the American dynamo who belted her way to stardom in this role and, together with Mandi Patinkin as Che (also a star making role) turned the not all that favorably received show into a hit. LuPone has the lustier pipes, but Roger, all fleet footed five feet of her, also delivers a fierce and feisty Eva. If her voice tends to turn shrill at times, that goes with the richly nuanced persona she creates. Like Lupone, Roger isn't a great beauty but a great talent. To see her in this Evita is to understand why this production has made her a star when this production had a run at London's Donmar Warehouse, as it did the original Eva, a star.

Since Roger is an unknown to American audiences and the Marquis is big theater, the role of the commentator has not only been changed but cast with big box office magnet performer. The change: This character was originally modeled after the beret wearing, cigar smoking, charismatic Revolutionary, Che Guevara who really had nothing to do with the Perons and was just a conceit to add a piquant edge to the story. Now he's just Che, a troubadour-narrator who stands a bit aside from the Evita smitten crowd. That brings us to the big star attraction, Spanish pop star Ricky Martin. The more anonymous, first name only Everyman works well for the tall, dark and handsome Martin. He sings well and what he lacks in edge he more than makes up for with relaxed stage presence and charm.

Much as I liked Roger, and Martin, if I were pressed to choose one of the above the title names for the Best Actor in a Musical Revival , it would be Michael Cerveris as the usually less talked about Juan Peron (In case you forgot, it was Bob Gunton back in 1979). The always superb singer-actor is in splendid voice and energizes the entire stage whenever he appears.

Also excellent additions to this American cast is Max Von Essen as Magaldi who was the first of the beds that represented the steps on Eva Duarte's climb to love, wealth, power and fame. Rachel Potter makes a strong impression as the Peron mistress Eva ousts. It's bad news for the character, but leads to Potter's lovely solo of "Another Suitcase in Another Hall."

Mr. Grandage's direction fluidly moves from the opening funeral scene backwards to the flashback from the opening funeral back to Eva's home town where she hooks up Magaldi and then on to an amusing scene that shows her dispatching one lover after another. The entry of Peron in her life and on the national scene is beautifully illustrated with "The Art of the Possible" and a stunning ritualistic dance that shows Peron getting rid of his opposition with a group of foot stomping colonels. This fluidity of sung and danced through story telling continues right through to the Peron wedding ceremony, her touching wheelchair scene and final "Lament."

People not hung up on comparisons with Patti and Mandi comparisons will probably be most enthralled with this fine, fresh take on the thirty-year-old show. But those who leave their tendency to compare and nitpick at home, will be grateful to Michael Grandage for not sticking slavishly to the old, and letting his own vision give theatergoers the best of the old and a timely and well worth seeing something new.
For Lizzie Loveridge's review of the 2006 Donmar Warehouse production go here.

Lyrics by Tim Rice
Music by Andrew Lloyd Webber
DIrected by Michael Grandage
Choreography by Rob Ashford
Cast: Ricky Martin (Che), Elena Roger (Eva), Christina DeCicco (Eva at Wed and Sat matinees)Michael Cerveris (PerĂ³n), Max von Essen (Magaldi) and Rachel Potter (Mistress), Maya Jade Frank and Isabella (alternating as Child)
Ensenble: Ashley Amber, George Lee Andrews, Eric L. Christian, Kristine Covillo, Ensemble Colin Cunliffe, Margot de la Barre,Bradley Dean, Rebecca Eichenberger, Melanie Field, Constantine Germanacos, Laurel Harris, Bahiyah Hibah, Nick Kenkel, Brad Little,Erica Mansfield, Emily Mechler, Sydney Morton, Jessica Lea Patty, Aleks Pevec, Rachel Potter, Kristie Dale Sanders, Timothy Shew, Johnny Stellard, Alex Michael Stoll, Daniel Torres
Swings: Wendi Bergamini, Jennie Ford, Michaeljon Slinger, Matt Wall. Sets and Costumes: Christopher Oram
Lighting: Neil Austin
Sound: Mick Potter
Wig and hair design: Richard Mawbey
Projections: Zachary Borovay
Technical supervision: Christopher C. Smith
Stage manager: Michael J. Passar
Music supervisor/conductor: Kristen Blodgette
Orchestrations: Mr. Lloyd Webber and David Cullen
Dance arrangements: David Chase
Music coordinator: David Lai
Running time: 2 hours 15 minutes including intermission
Marquis Theater, 1535 Broadway, at 45th Street
From 3/12/12; opening 4/05/12
Monday - Saturday @8pm; Wednesday and Saturday @2pm; Tuesday @7pm
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer 4/10/12
Musical Numbers
Act One
  • Requiem/The Company
  • Oh What a Circus/Che and Company
  • On This Night of a Thousand Stars/Magaldi
  • Eva Beware of the City/Magaldi, Eva, Che and Family
  • Buenos Aires/Eva, Che and Company
  • Goodnight and Thank You/Che, Eva and Lovers
  • The Art of the Possible/Peron, Eva and Officerss
  • Charity Concert/Magaldi, Che, Peron and Company
  • I'd Be Surprisingly Good For You/Eva and Peron
  • Another Suitcase in Another Hall/Mistress
  • Peron's Latest Flame/Che and Company
  • A New Argentina/Peron, Eva, Che and Company
Act Two
  • On the Balcony of the Casa Rosada/ Peron and Comany
  • Don't Cry for Me Argentina/Eva
  • High Flying, Adored/Che and Eva
  • Rainbow High/Eva and Valets
  • Rainbow Tour/ Peron,Che, Eva, and Company
  • The Chorus Girl Hasn't Learned/Eva and the Company
  • And the Money Kept Rolling In/Che and Company
  • Santa Evita/Child and Xompany
  • Waltz for Eva and Che/Eva and Che
  • You Must Love Me/Eva and Che
  • She is a Diamond/Peron and Officers
  • Dice Are Rolling/Peron and Eva
  • Eva's Final Broadcast/Eva
  • Montage/The Company
  • Lament/Eva
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Evita
  • I disagree with the review of Evita
  • The review made me eager to see Evita
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

Visit Curtainup's Blog Annex
For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted add to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter
Subscribe to our FREE email updates: E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message. If you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
Slings & Arrows  cover of  new Blu-Ray cover
Slings & Arrows- view 1st episode free

Anything Goes Cast Recording Anything Goes Cast Recording
Our review of the show

Book Of Mormon MP4 Book of Mormon -CD
Our review of the show

©Copyright 2012, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from