CurtainUp
CurtainUp
The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings
HOME PAGE

SITE GUIDE

SEARCH


REVIEWS

REVIEW ARCHIVES

ADVERTISING AT CURTAINUP

FEATURES

NEWS
Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


LISTINGS
Broadway
Off-Broadway

NYC Restaurants

BOOKS and CDs

OTHER PLACES
Berkshires
London
California
New Jersey
DC
Connecticut
Philadelphia
Elsewhere

QUOTES

TKTS

PLAYWRIGHTS' ALBUMS

LETTERS TO EDITOR

FILM

LINKS

MISCELLANEOUS
Free Updates
Masthead
A CurtainUp DC Review
Diner

Share
"It ain't no accident we're here tonight," .— the guys sing asthey have a reunion at the diner where they hung out in high school.
Diner
Adam Kantor (Eddie) and Josh Grisetti (Shrevie)
(Photo by Carol Rosegg)
How naive life in Baltimore in 1959 looks from the vantage point of 2014/5. Eisenhower was President, wars were at a minimum, technology had advanced as far as LP's.

As a bunch of guys reminisce in their high school hangout, a diner, the innocence of that decade provides a stark contrast to what we, the audience, know will follow — assassinations, the Vietnam War, civil rights movement, women's movement, mini-skirts, sexual liberation, drugs, the Rolling Stones, the 'net, Starbucks even the Baltimore-based tv series The Wire.

Not having seen the movie of the same name written by Barry Levinson, I have no means of comparing it to the musical now premiering at Signature Theatre. Multi-award winner Sheryl Crow provides the music and lyrics while Barry Levinson remains the writer. For the most part, their collaboration succeeds although some judicious pruning of repetitious dialogue, lyrics and superfluous characters would tighten what is now a too long show.

Sheryl Crow's take on the music of the '50's, particularly doo wop (a genre native to Baltimore), is well sung and truly enjoyable. The dancing is beautifully choreographed by Kathleen Marshall who also directs.

Whether the teens are slow dancing or jitterbugging a peppy number like "Darling, It's You" there is a sweetness to their moves. In fact there is a sweetness to the story line too.

The ruse for Levinson and Crow's trip down memory lane is a reunion prior to the wedding of one of the guys. We learn what happened to them post-1959 and the diner that was once their second home.

The characters though somewhat stock exude charm. Boogie (Derek Klena rocking a high and wide pompadour a la Elvis Presley and dancing as if his life depended on the beat) is the bad boy who ends up well. Modell (Bryan Fenkart) is a moocher. Billy (Aaron C. Finley, whose ballad "Please Be There" is sung exquisitely) is a moody good guy who does the right thing by his ambitious girl friend. Shrevie (Josh Grisetti) obsessed by his record collection and the music of his generation — Johnny Mathis or Sinatra, which?" he asks — does a terrific duet with Eddie (Adam Kantor) on the subject of marriage ironically titled "It's Good."

As for the women, the point is made often that the choices pre-Women's Lib were marriage or secretarial work. The exception was an occasional tv weather girl or assistant to a tv producer. Pre-marital sex was a no-no, and the bride-to-be's wedding is premised on the fact that she can answer a lengthy questionnaire about sports. As an anxious mother Maria Egler is very amusing in her small part and Whitney Bashor's Barbara leads the women in a very good song, "Don't," that warns of the traps women should try to avoid.

Where the script veers off on a tangent is in the first act finale as Fenwick (Matthew James Thomas) flings himself about an on-stage Christmas tableau while singing "Last Man Standing," nice song but superfluous in this context. However, several of Crow's songs including the ballads "For What it's Worth" and "Letting Go," sung slowly and with depth of feeling, should do well in a cabaret repertoire.

Derek McLane's and James Kronzer's scenic design supplies a real down-home feel to the diner. All that's missing is the aroma of stale coffee and sticky table tops. Paul Tazewell's costumes with the flouncy skirts for jitterbugging and twin sets and pearls for cooking and cleaning at home are faithful reminders of just how dull clothing was before the Swinging '60's.

Diner the musical has had one false start start at a regional theaters as well as a cancelled Broadway production. But never mind its checkered past, with some serious editing the show has a promising future.

Diner
Book by Barry Levinson
Music & Lyrics by Sheryl Crow
Based on the motion picture written and directed by Barry Levinson
Directed and Choreographed by Kathleen Marshall
Scenic Design by Derek McLane and James Kronzer
Costume Design by Paul Tazewell
Cast: John Schiappa (Older Boogie, Bagel); Bryan Fenkart (Modell); Adam Kantor (Eddie); Josh Grisetti (Shrevie); Tess Soltau (Elyse); Erika Henningsen (Beth); Derek Klena (Boogie); Maria Egler (Eddie's Mother/ensemble); Aaron C. Finley (Billy); Whitney Bashor (Barbara); Colleen Hayes (Carol Heathrow/ensemble); Lou Steele (Howard/ doo wop guy/ensemble); Mitch Marois (Methan); MaryLee Adams (Salon Receptionist/ ensemble/dance captain); Russell Sunday (Tank/ensemble); John Leslie Wolfe (Eddie's Father/ensemble); Nova Y. Payton (stripper/ensemble); Ben Lurye (doo wop guy/ensemble), Mitch Marois (doo wop guy/ensemble), David Rowen (doo wop guy/ensemble).
Musicians: Lon Hoyt (conductor/piano); Ben Bokor (saxophones); Victor Simonson (keyboard); Dan Hovey (guitar); Bill Hones (bass); Joe McCarthy (drums).
Running time: 2 hours and 30 minutes including one intermission.
Signature Theater, 4200 Campbell Avenue, Arlington, Va. 22206; www.signature-theatre.org; tickets start at $40 but most performances are sold out; 703-573-7328; December 9, 2014 to January 25, 2015.
Review based on December 27 at 8 performance.
Musical Numbers
Act One
    Ain't No Accident/ Eddie, Shrevie, Modell, Fenwick, Beth and Elyse
    What Would You Bet?/ Boogie, Fenwick, Shrevie, Eddie and Modell
    Working On a Brand New Groove/ Boogie, Eddie, Fenwick, Shrevie, Modell and Company
    Now and Then/Doo Wop Guys
    Please Be There/Billy
    Don't Give It All Away/Company
    It's Good/ Shrevie and Eddie
    Tear Down This House/ Beth and housewives
    Last Man Standing/Fenwick and Wise Men
Act Two
    Last Man Standing (reprise)/Billy, Shrevie and Eddie
    Letting Go/Fenwick
    You've Got A Lot To Learn/Eddie, Boogie and Guys
    Don't/Barbara and the women
    Darling, It's You/Boogie, Beth and Beauty Salon customers
    The Games We Play/Billy, Shrevie, Modell, Fenwick, Boogie, Eddie and Elyse
    For What It's Worth/Boogie, Beth and Older Boogie
    Every Man Needs a Woman/Barbara, Elyse and women
    Gotta Lotta Woman/Billy, Eddie, Shrevie, Boogie, Fenwick, Modell and Stripper
    The Wedding/ Company
    Now and Then (reprise)/Doo Wop guys
The New Similes Dictionary
New Similes Dictionary


Slings & Arrows  cover of  new Blu-Ray cover
Slings & Arrows- view 1st episode free



Book Of Mormon MP4 Book of Mormon -CD
Our review of the show amazon




©Copyright 2014, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from esommer@curtainup.com