The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings
A CurtainUp Review
They'll shoot me I don't care down with Big Brother. Thought crime does not entail death: thoughtcrime is death.—--Winston Smith
l-r: Gregory Konow as Winston Smith and Dustin Olson as O'Brien in 1984
(Photo: Lucas Noonan)
George Orwell's 1984 has been turned into a play a number of times, and at least once into a movie. I'm pretty sure this is the first production of it I've seen, although several years ago I reviewed Animal Farm as part of The Orwell Project which paired that play and 1984 (also using Alan Lyddiard adaptation and reviewed by Elyse Sommer--see link below). Godlight Theatre Company's production of 1984 is best when it's simplest. The chemistry between Winston (Gregory Konow) and Julia (Enid Cortes) in their love scenes and Winston's brutal interrogation and subsequent betrayal are the core of this adaptation of Orwell's famous novel. Unfortunately, the rest of the piece lags, bogged down by too many actors, scenes and sound effects.

1984 seems so ubiquitous by now that it's hard to imagine anyone not familiar with the story of Winston Smith, an Everyman trapped in a soulless dystopian future. Even his last name, Smith, shouts Joe Average. Freedom is Slavery, Ignorance is Strength run the play's slogans. Human emotion has been almost crushed out of existence, but Winston is determined to harbor some small shred of humanity. He begins an illicit love affair, starts a diary, tries to seek out like-minded citizens who also hate Big Brother. Unfortunately, his efforts come to a vicious and sudden stop. The authorities arrest him and, not satisfied with mere torture, are determined to completely reprogram his traitorous brain.

The production, while visually appealing, is almost too crowded for the tiny space at 59E59. The four women, who play the omnipresent Telescreens (used to spy on the populace), move around the playing square and station themselves at the four corners, thereby breaking the stage's continuity. An actual screen would be just as if not more effective. The short scenes which introduce various secondary characters break up the central Winston/Julia arc, and the lighting; and the sound effects, while innovative and completely in tune with the spirit of the play, often overpower the human element. An apt metaphor, I realize, but still distracting.

This gets back to my comment that the piece is best when it's simplest. . .when the production is stripped of the extra people, the extra effects, and it's just two people in a cramped space, attempting to connect on any human level—— and that's the metaphor that counts. Gregory Konow as Winston and Enid Cortes as Julia have a simple and lovely chemistry onstage. Dustin Olsen as O'Brien is the other standout. His torture scene with Winston is far more effective, and powerful, than all the narrative and backstory leading up to it. In fact, the message of the novel and the play can be derived from that one scene alone. To be sure, torture scenes are obviously difficult, especially these days with all the talk of waterboarding in the news. However, this particular torture scene is well-balanced and emotionally compelling without being graphic. The two men never even touch.

Considering the power of the Winston/O'Brien scene had me almost wish Joe Tantalo had skipped more of the first part of the story, though I admit cutting most of the backstory from a play that runs 85 minutes is a little extreme. But then the directorial business was also extreme enough to become distracting during the narrative scenes. Still, consider my quibbles minor since Mr. Tantalo and his actors ultimately give us an accurate rendering of the novel's spirit.

Editor's Note: The Godlight Theater Company has built a reputation in the New York's Off-Broadway theater world for producing difficult to stage works that offer what one of our critics called "stealth commentary" about the human condition. Here are links to their previously reviewed productions:
Slaughterhouse Five
Fahrenheit 451
Clockwork Orange

You might also want to read Curtainup's review of 1984 and Animal Farm that were part of the 2004 Orwell Project.

Based on the novel by George Orwell
Adapted by Alan Lyddiard
Directed by Joe Tantalo
With Gregory Konow (Winston Smith), Dustin Olson (O'Brien), Enid Cortes (Julia), Aaron Paternoster (Syme), Nick Pagliano (Parsons), Michael Tranzilli (Charrington), Michael Shimkin (Goldstein), and Deanna McGovern, Katherine Boynton, Sammy Tunis and Scarlett Thiele as the Telescreens
Original Music and Sound Design: Andrew Recinos
Production Design: Maruti Evans
Choreographer: Hachi Yu
Running Time: 85 minutes with no intermission
Godlight Theatre Company, 59E59, 59 East 59th Street; 212-279-4200
From 3/13/09; opening 3/25/09; closing 4/19/09.
Tickets $25 ($15 for 59E59 Members).
Tuesday 7:30 pm, Wednesday through Friday at 8:30 pm, Saturday 2:30 and 8:30 pm, Sunday 3:30 pm
Reviewed by Jenny Sandman based on March 22nd performance
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of 1984
  • I disagree with the review of 1984
  • The review made me eager to see 1984
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

You can also contact us at Curtainup at Facebook or Curtainup at Twitter
South Pacific  Revival
South Pacific

In the Heights
In the Heights

Playbill 2007-08 Yearbook

Leonard Maltin's Classic Movie Guide
Leonard Maltin's 2008 Movie Guide


©Copyright 2009, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from